Smallville's Supernatural Crossover: 13 Actors Who Appeared in Both

Article Overview

Actors from Smallville and Supernatural have appeared in both shows, showcasing their versatility across different roles and storylines.

The characters they played encompassed a wide range - from romantic partners to antagonists, even to intricate protagonists - which brought richness and variety to the overall storyline.

While a crossover between Smallville and Supernatural never materialized, there were instances of guest appearances and interconnections between the two shows, providing fans with a glimpse into what could have been.

With both Supernatural and Smallville running for several seasons on The CW, it's not surprising that there are actors who have connections to both shows. Supernatural follows the Winchester brothers as they fight supernatural beings and cosmic entities, while Smallville offers an origin story about Superman, or Clark Kent, as he navigates the real world and protects his loved ones.

Interestingly, despite their thematic and tonal differences, these two shows have more in common than just shared actors. There was almost a crossover between Smallville and Supernatural, but it never materialized. However, fans got a taste of it when Tom Welling, who played the lead in Smallville, made a guest appearance as the brothers' grandfather on Supernatural's prequel series, The Winchesters. It's intriguing to see how many actors from both shows have collaborated either prior to Supernatural on Smallville or the other way around.

13. Sara Canning As Lydia / Kat

Supernatural Season 7 / Smallville Season 8

In the world of Canning's Lydia, a fierce Amazon woman from a tribe that forfeits the lives of men they mate with, a surprising twist unfolds when her one-night affair with Dean unravels his unexpected journey into fatherhood during season 7. However, to rescue Dean, Sam finds himself compelled to take Lydia's life which turns this episode into a captivating portrayal of the unfortunate outcomes that can arise from Dean's casual encounters. Prior to this, Canning made a brief appearance in Smallville during season 8 as Kat, the dedicated personal assistant to Tess Mercer.

12. Ian Tracey As Lee Chambers and Ishim / Lincoln Cole

Supernatural Season 7 and 12 / Smallville Season 5

Tracey appeared on Supernatural, portraying two significant yet contrasting characters. The first was Lee Chambers, a tenacious hunter who tragically meets his demise and leaves behind his daughter, Krissy. Additionally, she also portrayed Ishim, a commanding angel who harbors a deep animosity towards Castiel following the fall of the angels. Ishim's life is ultimately ended by Castiel, after engaging in a fierce struggle against Sam and Dean, who were attempting to aid Lily, a human empowered by angelic forces seeking retribution for her daughter's death. In addition to her role on Supernatural, Tracey made a chilling mark on Smallville as Lincoln. Lincoln's sinister deeds involve the abduction of Lionel Luthor, whom he subjects to mind-bending puzzles and enigmatic riddles. Later, he captures Martha Kent to further intensify Lionel's torment.

11. Emmanuelle Vaugier As Madison / Dr. Helen Bryce

Supernatural Season 2 / Smallville Season 2 and 3

Vaugier's role in Supernatural is crucial, as she becomes Sam's first genuine love interest after the tragic death of his girlfriend, Jessica. Madison, a werewolf, becomes the focus of Sam and Dean's efforts to find a cure, but unfortunately, their attempts are unsuccessful. When Madison realizes that she will forever be a werewolf and doesn't want to harm innocent people, she asks Sam to end her life. Despite their burgeoning romance, Sam reluctantly fulfills her request, deepening his emotional turmoil.

In Smallville, Vaugier portrays Dr. Helen Bryce, who becomes Lex Luthor's second wife in a recurring role. Despite professing her love for Lex, Helen orchestrates a plan to cause their plane to crash during their honeymoon in season 2. She also betrays Clark by selling a vial of his blood to Lionel and informing Morgan Edge. Helen is characterized by her frequent lies, attempts to kill Lex, and her ability to evade capture. However, Lex eventually uncovers her true intentions, bringing an end to her manipulative schemes.

10. Robert Picardo As Wayne Whittaker Jr. and Leprechaun / Edward Teague

Supernatural Season 6 / Smallville Season 4

Although Picardo's appearance on Supernatural occurred after his brief stint on Smallville, it took place in one of the show's most peculiar episodes. In this particular installment, Picardo portrays a leprechaun disguised as Wayne Whittaker Jr., a self-proclaimed expert on UFOs. The episode delves into a twisted plot involving fairies and the leprechaun, who demand the sacrifice of firstborn sons in order to be summoned. Despite offering Sam a solution to recover his soul, a crucial objective in season 6, Sam manages to overcome and defeat him, completing the necessary spell to banish both the fairies and the leprechaun.

Picardo portrays Edward Teague in Smallville, where he portrays a lawyer and member of the Veritas society in search of The Traveler (Clark). He is also the father of Jason Teague, played by Jensen Ackles, who tragically passes away at the conclusion of Season 4. Following the deaths of his wife and son, Edward quietly becomes a member of the priesthood, offscreen. He later subdues Clark using a Kryptonian ritual and, unfortunately, meets his demise in a plane crash after being threatened by Brainiac.

9. Julia Maxwell As Eve / Mary Pierson

Supernatural Season 6 / Smallville Season 8

While Eve's character was intended to be powerful as the Mother of All, her lifespan is short-lived. Nevertheless, Maxwell skillfully conveys her enigmatic essence with an unsettling calmness. An instance of this is when Eve enters a bar and transforms everyone present into hybrid supernatural beings. Prior to this, during her time on Smallville, she exhibits unique powers. In one episode, she assumes the role of Mary Pierson, a metahuman with the ability to manipulate electricity, attending Chloe's counseling meetings at the Isis Foundation. Despite her intriguing powers, such as the capacity to illuminate lights and amplify electrical charges in electronic devices, she meets her demise when captured by Davis in his Doomsday form.

8. Christopher Heyerdahl As Alastair / Zor-El

Supernatural Season 4 / Smallville Season 7

7. Tyler Johnston As Samandriel and Matt Pike / Randy Klein

Heyerdahl effectively portrays the demon Alastair, the merciless torturer of hell, embodying his sadistic nature and bone-chilling voice while also showing signs of masochism. Alastair's role is pivotal in Dean's character development as he subjects him to torment in hell for three decades, causing Dean to eventually become a torturer himself. This traumatic experience deeply impacts Dean's self-perception and emotional stability, which he opens up about to Sam in a heartfelt conversation during the fourth season. In Smallville, Heyerdahl exhibits similar qualities as a controlling scientist from Krypton who bears responsibility for the destruction of his home planet. He goes to extreme lengths, including plotting the murder of his own daughter Kara, and manipulates his nephew Clark in an ambitious quest to conquer Earth.

Supernatural Seasons 1 and 8 / Smallville Season 8

Johnston initially appears in one of Supernatural's lowest-rated episodes, "Bugs," as the character Matt, a young boy captivated by insects. Subsequently, he portrays Samandriel, an angel subject to torment by Crowley's demons, leading to the severance of his angelic connection. This significant turn of events aids Crowley in uncovering the secrets harbored within the angel tablet. Operating under the manipulation of Naomi, Castiel valiantly intervenes to rescue Samandriel, who, after exposing the confidential revelations of heaven, adamantly refuses to return. Tragically, Castiel feels compelled to assassinate him.

Like Maxwell, Johnston also portrays a character infected with Kryptonite on the television show Smallville. His character, Randy Klein, possesses the ability to transform into a shadow-like form. He is introduced in the same episode as Maxwell and even attends the same counseling session. Randy causes chaos by attacking Jimmy Olsen and Davis, claiming to be the notorious serial killer at large during that time in order to gain attention. Although his character is troubled, his future remains uncertain as Tess offers him a position on her team of super-powered individuals.

6. Tahmoh Penikett As Gadreel / Wes Keenan and Vince Davis

Supernatural Season 9 / Smallville Seasons 3 and 6

Penikett assumes a significant role in Supernatural as the fallen angel Gadreel, who plays a covert part in healing Sam. Following Sam's unsuccessful attempt to seal the gates of hell, Gadreel secretly possesses him. While assisting Metatron, who manipulates him into killing Kevin Tran, he eventually joins forces with the Winchesters to overthrow Metatron, thus becoming a prominent figure in the storyline of season 9. In Smallville, Penikett portrays two characters; Vince Davis in season 3 and Wes Keenan in season 6. Vince's life is tragically cut short by a liver disease, only to resurrect himself using the Lazarus serum, although ultimately succumbing to the ailment once again. Wes, on the other hand, is a childhood friend and former romantic interest of Lois Lane, who later enlists as a soldier. Presumed dead while on active duty, he is transformed into a successful prototype super-soldier, meticulously engineered by LuthorCorp.

5. Samantha Ferris As Ellen / Warden Anita Stone

Supernatural Seasons 2, 5-6 / Smallville Season 4

Ellen's death in Supernatural is truly heart-wrenching, and Ferris delivers a remarkable performance as the no-nonsense bar owner and hunter. She brings a powerful female presence to the early seasons and quickly becomes an integral part of Sam and Dean's chosen family. In season 6, her return as Bobby's wife, due to a clever rewriting of history, offers a bittersweet glimpse into the character's significance to Bobby and the brothers. On the other hand, Ferris makes a guest appearance in Smallville, portraying the role of Warden Anita Stone. In the single episode she appears in, Stone's sole purpose is to inform Lionel that his conviction for murdering his parents has been overturned.

4. Ty Olsson As Benny / Officer Talbert

Supernatural Seasons 8 and 10 / Smallville Season 8

Olsson's portrayal of Benny, the vampire in Supernatural, is remarkable. Benny plays a crucial role in helping Dean escape Purgatory. His character is driven by a strong desire to avenge his soulmate's supposed death. Throughout the series, Benny's growth is evident as he keeps a watchful eye on his only living descendant and remains dedicated to not killing. His unwavering commitment to helping Dean and offering him a rare friendship is what makes Benny a memorable character in the show. Furthermore, he selflessly sacrifices himself to reside in Purgatory in order to bring Sam back. In Smallville, Olsson assumes the role of Talbert, a corrupt cop who attempts to murder a defenseless Martian Manhunter.

3. Adrianne Palicki As Jessica Moore / Lindsey Harrison (Kara)

Supernatural Season 1, 2, and 5 / Smallville Season 3

Palicki's role as Jessica on Supernatural goes beyond just screen time. She is a pivotal character that influences Sam's decision to become a hunter, his complicated feelings about love and relationships, and his encounters with grief. Even after Jessica's tragic death, she continues to haunt Sam through visions and dreams, which are eventually revealed to be manipulations by Lucifer. Before joining Supernatural, Palicki made a memorable appearance in Smallville season 3, playing a car crash survivor named Kara who pretends to be a Kryptonian woman trying to entice Clark away from his adoptive family.

2. Alaina Huffman As Abbadon / Dinah Lance and Black Canary

Supernatural Seasons 8-9 / Smallville Season 7-10

Huffman embodies the character of Josie, a woman overtaken by the formidable Knight of Hell, Abaddon. Abaddon plays a pivotal role as an antagonist, relentlessly vying for control of hell, ultimately driving Dean to seek the First Blade and bear the Mark Of Cain. Although a thorn in the side of Team Free Will, Josie's captivating presence and immense power give rise to riveting storylines throughout seasons 8 and 9. In her portrayal of Black Canary, also known as Dinah Lance, Huffman finds herself on the side of justice in the realm of Smallville. Over the course of three seasons, she becomes an integral part of the Justice League, working closely alongside the resilient Green Arrow.

1. Jensen Ackles – Dean Winchester / Jason Teague

Supernatural Season 1-15 / Smallville Season 4

Playing both fan-favorite Dean on Supernatural and Jason Teague in season 4, Ackles showcases his talent as a seasoned actor. In Smallville, he takes on the role of Jason, who is the son of Picardo's character. Jason is a college student, an assistant coach for Smallville High's football team, and enjoys a relationship with Lana after meeting her in Paris. Encouraged by his mother, he embarks on a quest to locate the Kryptonian stones necessary to access Clark's Fortress of Solitude. Tragically, his mother is killed during this mission, leading Jason to hold Clark's parents hostage in his belief that Clark is the key. In a devastating turn of events, Jason meets his demise during a meteor shower. However, it is Ackles' portrayal of Dean that truly stands out. Dean is a complex and flawed hero, confronting loss, inner conflict, and extraordinary challenges throughout the Supernatural series. Ultimately, his heartbreaking demise occurs in the show's finale.

Editor's P/S

As a passionate fan of both Smallville and Supernatural, I was thrilled to discover the surprising connections between these two beloved shows. The article highlights 13 actors who appeared in both series, showcasing their versatility and range across different roles and storylines. It's fascinating to see how these actors brought their unique talents to both shows, creating memorable characters that enriched the overall narratives.

One of the most intriguing aspects of this crossover is the way in which the actors were able to portray vastly different characters in each show. For example, Sara Canning played the fierce Amazon warrior Lydia in Supernatural, while in Smallville, she portrayed the dedicated personal assistant Kat. Similarly, Erica Cerra appeared as the cunning and ruthless vampire Ruby in Supernatural, but in Smallville, she played the kind-hearted and compassionate Chloe Sullivan. These actors seamlessly transitioned between these contrasting roles, demonstrating their incredible range and versatility as performers.

The article also mentions the potential for a crossover between Smallville and Supernatural, which never materialized. As a fan, I can't help but wonder what could have been. Imagine the excitement of seeing the Winchester brothers team up with Clark Kent to battle supernatural threats or the clash between the Smallville crew and the forces of Heaven and Hell. While a full-fledged crossover never came to fruition, the guest appearances and interconnections between the two shows provided fans with tantalizing glimpses into this potential shared universe.