Shocking Plot Twist: Is Alicia Really Dead in Fear The Walking Dead Season 8?

Warning: Spoilers for Fear the Walking Dead season 8, episode 7

Summary

Alicia's shocking death in season 8 of Fear the Walking Dead raises uncertainty as Troy returns unexpectedly, claiming to be responsible for her demise. However, no solid evidence exists to confirm her fate.

If Troy were to be the one responsible for Alicia's death, it would have a devastating impact on Madison. Alicia, being her only surviving child, held immense significance to her. Moreover, Madison's ultimate desire for revenge lies not in destroying PADRE, but in killing Alicia.

In a startling turn of events, it is explicitly stated in Fear the Walking Dead that Alicia has died. While the possibility of this beloved character meeting an untimely demise was hinted at in the midseason finale of season 8, the spinoff has taken this insinuation to a whole new level. If the shocking revelation in Fear the Walking Dead holds true, it means that one of its most prominent characters has been killed off.

Following up on the show's setup for Troy's return, Fear the Walking Dead season 8 officially retconned his death in the midseason premiere. In a surprising turn of events, Daniel Sharman's character, Troy Otto, enters the scene as the leader of the spinoff's final villains, leaving Madison Clark speechless. Astonishingly, Troy managed to survive what was once believed to be a fatal injury in season 3 and has now resurfaced seeking revenge. Not only does he have his sights set on PADRE, but Troy also seems to have targeted Alicia. His references to Madison's daughter tragically confirm one of the main theories stemming from the Fear the Walking Dead midseason finale's conclusion.

Troy Claims He Killed Alicia In Fear The Walking Dead

In parting ways with Alicia Debnam-Carey after seven seasons, the spinoff cleverly set the stage for her potential comeback by introducing a surprising twist regarding her supposed death. Throughout season 7, Alicia believed she had contracted the zombie virus and was slowly succumbing to its effects. Tearfully bidding farewell to Strand and the rest of the group, she accepted her impending fate. However, the episode's conclusion confirmed what many had already suspected: Alicia was not, in fact, dying. It appeared that her symptoms were the result of an entirely different illness.

When Fear the Walking Dead parted ways with Alicia, she embarked on a journey to unknown territories. Remaining in Texas, where the aftermath of the nuclear bomb in season 6's finale still lingered, Alicia appeared to begin a fresh chapter in the zombie apocalypse. This new chapter held the potential for a happy ending for her, as she could possibly form a new group of survivors. On-screen, it was easy to envision this kind of future for Alicia. However, Troy revealed that any hope of such a future was abruptly dashed. With the production of Alicia's fake arm, Troy confessed to killing her and leaving her reanimated corpse behind. No further information was given regarding the circumstances of their encounter.

Why Alicia Might Still Be Alive

Although Troy's revelation deeply impacts Madison and introduces a significant plot twist, it does not definitively confirm Alicia's fate in Fear the Walking Dead. While her fake arm is now in Troy's possession, it is not solid evidence of her demise. This revelation instills fear in Madison's mind, but without a proper flashback or a body, the truthfulness of Troy's claim cannot be verified. The arm only indicates that Troy managed to locate Alicia, or at least came across some traces of her. It is plausible that the arm was left behind at some point and later discovered by Troy during his search.

The possession of the arm by Troy strongly suggests that he had intentions of either killing or capturing Alicia. However, there is a possibility that he did not succeed in his plan. It is plausible that he acquired the arm while engaging in a struggle with Alicia but ultimately did not emerge victorious. If this scenario holds true, then it is possible that Alicia managed to survive. Nevertheless, since Troy possesses the arm, he would possess sufficient evidence to effectively lie and claim that Madison's daughter is deceased. The purpose of doing so would be to emotionally devastate his adversary, even if there remains a chance that Alicia is still alive and well within The Walking Dead's universe.

Troy Killing Alicia Would Make His FTWD Season 8 Revenge Arc Pointless

Troy's recent traumatic act against Madison suggests that his current objective may be futile. Instead of directly hurting Madison by preventing PADRE from becoming a safe haven, he should realize that her children have always been the central focus of her story in Fear the Walking Dead. Protecting their well-being has been her utmost priority since the beginning of the series. Losing Nick has already devastated Madison, leaving Alicia as her only surviving child. Therefore, it would make more sense for Troy to seek ultimate revenge by targeting Alicia's life, rather than destroying PADRE.

If Troy killed Alicia in revenge for Madison's actions towards him, there would be no need for him to further punish her by taking away PADRE. Having spent time with Alicia and Nick in season 3, Troy understands their importance to Madison. As her daughter, Madison valued Alicia's life more than her own, making her murder far more devastating than anything Troy could do to her in Fear the Walking Dead season 8 part 2. Ultimately, Troy may have already claimed victory before Madison even begins to fight. Watch new episodes of Fear the Walking Dead on Sundays on AMC.