Ridley Scott’s Response to TikTok Users Critiquing Inaccuracies in Napoleon: A Different Perspective
Ridley Scott's upcoming film on Napoleon Bonaparte faces scrutiny from history experts as inaccuracies are highlighted Dive into the debate surrounding the highly anticipated movie
Napoleon Bonaparte, a highly controversial figure in history, has been extensively depicted in films and TV series, even making appearances in children's cartoons for almost a century. In an upcoming historical biopic by Ridley Scott, the focus is on this self-made Emperor, with Joaquin Phoenix taking on the role and wearing the iconic bicorn hat.
Scott has previously taken creative liberties with historical events, as seen in his films Gladiator and Black Hawk Down. However, this does not hinder him from pursuing his unique style of filmmaking. His interest in Napoleon began more than 15 years ago, and upon the release of the first trailer, he faced immediate criticism from experts pointing out inaccuracies.
TV historian Dan Snow recently shared a TikTok video in which he analyzes the inaccuracies in a particular scene, while also commending Ridley Scott's filmmaking skills. "I am a fan of historical epics and have great admiration for Ridley Scott," Snow expressed. "Though we acknowledge this film is not a documentary, it undoubtedly possesses remarkable artistic qualities." Snow went on to clarify that, historically speaking, Napoleon did not engage in any pyramids-related battle and emphasized that Marie-Antoinette famously sported cropped hair during her execution. Additionally, Snow pointed out the geographical discrepancy, stating that Napoleon was actually in a different region of France at the time. Nevertheless, he acknowledged the scene's visual appeal.
Scott's response in The New Yorker for a profile piece: "Find a purpose."
In a prior interview with Empire magazine, Phoenix championed the film's cause. "If you truly wish to comprehend Napoleon, then undertaking your own research and reading is likely the best course of action," the Academy Award winner elucidated. "By watching this film, you are subjected to an account filtered through Ridley's perspective."
Napoleon arrives in theaters on November 22.
Editor's P/S
As a Gen Z netizen, I have mixed feelings about Ridley Scott's upcoming film on Napoleon Bonaparte. On the one hand, I am excited to see a new film about this fascinating historical figure. On the other hand, I am concerned about the inaccuracies that have been pointed out by experts.
I understand that Scott is not making a documentary, and I appreciate his unique style of filmmaking. However, I believe that it is important for historical films to be accurate, as they can have a significant impact on the public's understanding of history.
I am also concerned about the message that Scott's film sends about the importance of historical accuracy. By saying that people should "find a purpose" rather than worrying about inaccuracies, Scott seems to be suggesting that historical accuracy is not important. I believe that this is a dangerous message, as it could lead people to believe that it is acceptable to distort history for the sake of entertainment.
