Revisiting the Lie Detector Test: Could Casey Anthony Face Retrial?
Can Casey Anthony face a retrial? Discover the truth behind Casey Anthony's parents' lie detector tests and the implications they may have on her case
After the launch of the new A&E and Lifetime special "Casey Anthony’s Parents: The Lie Detector Test," the question is being raised once again: could Casey face a retrial for her daughter's death?
Certain cases remain relevant in the true crime community, such as Chris Watts, the focus of the Netflix documentary "American Murder" after murdering his family, Gypsy Rose whose recent release aligns with "The Prison Confessions" docu-series, as well as notorious serial killers like Jeffrey Dahmer and Ted Bundy.
The ongoing debate surrounding Casey Anthony is particularly contentious. In 2011, her murder trial began, three years after her daughter Caylee was found dead near their home. Despite significant evidence against her, the jury found her not guilty. Since then, Casey has made several accusations against her family, some of which were aired in the 2022 docu-series Casey Anthony: Where the Truth Lies. With a new documentary involving her parents, George and Cindy, there are questions about the possibility of a retrial. Warning: some may find this content distressing.
Can Casey Anthony be tried again?
Casey Anthony cannot be retried for the murder of Caylee due to the double jeopardy clause, which prohibits individuals from being prosecuted twice for the same crime, despite the hopes of true crime fans worldwide.
According to the definition by Cornell Law School, the Double Jeopardy Clause in the Fifth Amendment of the US Constitution prevents individuals from being prosecuted twice for the same crime. The specific section reads, "No person shall… be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb."
Given that Casey, previously known as the "most hated mom in America," was tried and cleared of all charges, she is shielded by this clause. Nevertheless, some specialists argue that Casey's parents, George and Cindy, may have grounds to file a defamation lawsuit against her following the outcomes of their lie detector tests.
What were the results of Casey Anthony’s parents’ lie detector tests?
During the documentary special, Casey Anthony’s Parents: The Lie Detector Test, it was revealed that both Cindy and George's lie detector test results showed that they were telling the truth about several accusations, including their assertion that they had no involvement in Caylee's death.
In Where the Truth Lies, George successfully passed a lie detector test, disproving several of Casey's accusations, including those of sexual assault against both Casey and Caylee. The conductor of the test confirmed George's truthfulness and expressed that he and Cindy deserved to be believed.
Before the documentary Casey Anthony’s Parents: The Lie Detector Test was released, experts had indicated that if the results were in favor of George and Cindy, they could pursue legal action against Casey for the allegations of child murder and sexual assault.
Richard Altman, an intellectual property lawyer in New York, informed The New York Post in November that if she made the statement during her trial, it would be considered privileged. However, if she made the statement outside of a court proceeding, it could be subject to legal action. Alan Lewis, a partner at Carter Ledyard & Milburn specializing in defamation cases, also stated that despite lie detector results, Casey's claims could lead to a potential legal case.
"The claim that so-and-so raped me is a verifiable statement that can be either substantiated or refuted, making it a form of defamation," Lewis stated. "In theory, does he have a viable legal case to pursue? It appears so."
We will continue to provide updates on any progress in the case.
Watch Casey Anthony’s Parents: The Lie Detector Test on Amazon Prime now. Sign up here, and check out our true crime coverage below:
- Natalia Speaks ending explained
- Natalia Grace’s real age
- Is Kristine Barnett in jail?
- Where is Natalia Grace now?
- Great Photo, Lovely Life explained
- Love Has Won’s “3D” hospital
- How did John Gotti die?
- Who Killed Jill Dando?
- Where is Gypsy Rose Blanchard now?
- Russell Brand most shocking moments
- Scouts Honor explained
- The Isabella Nardoni Case
- Who are the Duggars?
Please note that if you click on a product link on this page we may earn a small affiliate commission.
Editor's P/S
As a passionate true crime enthusiast, I have closely followed the Casey Anthony case for years. The recent A&E and Lifetime special, "Casey Anthony's Parents: The Lie Detector Test," has reignited discussions about the possibility of a retrial. While I understand the public's desire for justice, I believe that Casey cannot be retried due to the double jeopardy clause. The Fifth Amendment of the US Constitution protects individuals from being prosecuted twice for the same crime, and Casey was previously found not guilty in her murder trial.
However, the lie detector test results of Casey's parents, George and Cindy, have raised questions about their involvement in Caylee's death. The fact that both parents passed the test, indicating their truthfulness, could potentially lead to legal action against Casey for defamation. If Casey made false accusations of child murder and sexual assault outside of a court proceeding, she could be held liable for her statements. It is important to note that lie detector results are not admissible in court, but they can still be used as evidence in civil cases. As the legal experts mentioned in the article suggest, Casey's claims could lead to a potential defamation lawsuit.
