Ranking the 'After' Movie Series: From Best to Worst

1. After We Collided (2020) - A Scandalous Romantic Comedy

Surpassing its predecessors with a blend of intense drama and whimsical humor, 'After We Collided' emerges as the pinnacle of the 'After' movie series. The film's fresh take on romantic comedy, injected with the series' hallmark scandalous twists, provides an engaging exploration of Tessa and Hardin's rollercoaster relationship. Following their tumultuous breakup, we see Tessa thriving in her new role at a publishing company, juxtaposed with Hardin's introspective struggle with his past demons. The movie's pacing may falter, but it offers a captivating window into their passionate romance.

Trevor and Tessa in an elevator with small smiles in After We Collided

2. After Everything (2023) - A New Perspective

'After Everything' breaks away from the series' pattern by presenting Hardin's perspective, a refreshing change that enriches the viewers' understanding of his character. This fifth installment takes us through the aftermath of Hardin and Tessa's separation, offering a deeper dive into Hardin's attempts to better himself. Set against the picturesque backdrop of Portugal, the film provides a compelling narrative as Hardin reconnects with figures from his past. Despite a somewhat hasty conclusion, 'After Everything' stands out as a superior entry in the series, marked by its unique storytelling approach.

Hardin looks on wearing a suit in After Everything

3. After (2019) - The Beginning of the Saga

The original film, 'After,' sets the stage for Tessa and Hardin's intense affair but falls short in delivering the dramatic depth expected from such a storied relationship. Despite its shortcomings, the film's opening act establishes a solid foundation, capturing Tessa's conservative upbringing and her magnetic pull towards the enigmatic Hardin. The chemistry between the protagonists strengthens as the story unfolds, but character development remains limited. Nevertheless, Josephine Langford's standout performance adds a glimmer of promise to this introductory chapter of the 'After' series.

Tessa and Hardin sitting in a garden together in After

4. After Ever Happy (2022) - A Repetitive End

The fourth film, 'After Ever Happy,' regrettably continues the repetitive pattern established in earlier films, failing to offer audiences any novel twists or character developments. Hardin's recurring bad boy persona feels worn, and the movie's attempt to break the mold with a final breakup does little to salvage its innovation deficiency. Despite its predictable nature, the film's conclusion still manages to resonate, owing to the extensive history shared by the central characters. The stark divide between critical reception and fan enjoyment is most evident here, with audience approval surprisingly high compared to the underwhelmed critics.

Tessa and Hardin smiling at each other in After Ever Happy