Ranking The 6 Seasons of Lucifer from Worst to Best

Summary

Lucifer's third season was the weakest out of the six seasons, with predictable plot twists and an overly obvious character arc for Lt. Marcus Pierce.

Lucifer's first season had a challenging time blending realistic and mystical aspects, but it did excel at developing strong characters like Amenadiel and Dr. Linda Martin.

Season 5 marked the pinnacle of Lucifer's story, as it skillfully integrated a range of storylines including evil doppelgängers and a heated political rivalry between Michael and Lucifer. This season also solidified the Deckerstar relationship and highlighted Lucifer's remarkable personal growth.

The show "Lucifer" revolved around the Devil using his crime-solving abilities in Los Angeles. While the series had a captivating run, not all seasons lived up to their full potential. Originally airing on FOX, the show moved to Netflix after its initial cancellation, allowing for a exploration of darker themes and a more authentic adaptation of the comics. This exploration opened up numerous possibilities for intriguing plotlines, further enhanced by the fantastic cast of characters. From beginning to end, "Lucifer" maintained its core concept, following the partnership between an LAPD detective and the Devil as they tackled various crimes, both human and biblical in nature. The show delved into the complicated relationship between Detective Decker and Lucifer as they confronted the realities of heaven and hell together. With a perfect blend of drama, romance, and comedy, "Lucifer" has become one of the finest TV shows of its genre throughout its six-season run, although we won't be seeing a seventh season.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

6. Lucifer Season 3

Although season 3 of Lucifer may not be terrible, it is undeniably the weakest out of the show's six seasons. These episodes were filled with predictable plot twists. The season picks up immediately after Lucifer regains his wings. Considering his ongoing struggle with this aspect, it is understandable that they resurface once again. Lieutenant Marcus Pierce, portrayed by Tom Welling, is introduced as a new character, only to later be revealed as Cain. It was evident that he would play a more significant role in the supernatural narrative than initially suggested. Additionally, his character transformation, veering between good and evil, was quite obvious.

Lucifer season 3 witnessed the remarkable evolution of the relationship between Chloe and Lucifer, delighting fans of the couple. Another character who experienced significant development in this season is Dr. Linda Martin. Her compelling backstory was finally explored, revealing her ex-husband's discovery of Lucifer's true identity and his obsessive tendencies towards Linda. The most dramatic moment occurred during Lucifer's final battle with Peirce, where his intense anger led to the revelation of his true face to Chloe, thereby igniting her character's subsequent plot against Lucifer.

5. Lucifer Season 1

Lucifer's first season was marked by a struggle to define its identity. It grappled with finding the right balance between its realistic and mystical elements. At times, this caused an unevenness in the storytelling. For instance, the inclusion of a dirty cop subplot felt out of place in a show centered around the supernatural. It didn't align with Lucifer's core purpose as a character. However, it did provide context for the supporting cast. Additionally, there were supernatural elements that seemed disconnected from the involvement of the police officers, but their presence was necessary for the overall plot.

There are a few standout characters in the series, and among them, Amenadiel truly shines as one of the best. Throughout the first season, he exemplifies his multifaceted nature, blending innocence with a lack of awareness about his surroundings, effectively portraying an angel. Another exceptional character is Dr. Martin, Lucifer's therapist. Her journey of growth and development, all the while remaining skeptical of Lucifer's true identity as the devil, adds an intriguing element to the story. Additionally, the exploration of Lucifer's vulnerability when he is around Chloe creates an engaging plotline that seamlessly carries into the second season.

4. Lucifer Season 4

At the onset of Lucifer season 4, watching it proved to be quite challenging. The show, known for delving into the intricacies of human emotions, particularly those experienced by characters grappling with their friend's profound secret, presents a disorienting scenario. In Chloe's case, she seeks assistance from a group of Priests in order to target Lucifer, with the intention of ending his life. This particular development sets a peculiar tone for the season and feels incongruent with Chloe's established character. What's more, it unnecessarily generates conflict between Chloe and Lucifer, thus undermining the escalating tension in their budding relationship.

Besides the main plot, Lucifer season 4 introduces a number of shocking moments that leave viewers captivated. Not only do the side characters experience their own struggles and dilemmas, but the season takes an unexpected turn when Amenadiel and Dr. Martin discover they are having a baby together. Despite the seemingly impossible odds, this surprising twist becomes a focal point for their characters throughout most of the season. However, this shift in focus contrasts with the development of other characters and storylines, creating a slight imbalance within the overall narrative.

3. Lucifer Season 2

The second season of Lucifer had a stronger beginning than its predecessor, featuring several captivating plotlines that further developed the characters. One notable example is the exploration of the complex relationship between Lucifer, Amenadiel, and their mother. The show delves into their connection, highlighting the fact that she seemingly abandoned them during their childhood. Struggling to regain her place in heaven, their mother faces the disintegration of the body she took after escaping Hell. As they navigate the intricacies of their family dynamic, the sons and their mother experience both highs and lows.

This season also includes other significant twists. One of the most notable is Lucifer finally disclosing his true identity to someone – his therapist, Dr. Linda Martin. Surprisingly, she handles this news fairly well, and it becomes captivating to witness the transformation of their friendship during this period. Furthermore, this season also showcases some of the most comical episodes. A particular favorite is episode 14 of season 2, titled "Candy Morningstar," wherein Lucifer returns from Vegas with a supposed wife. Although it is eventually revealed that they were never truly married, the resulting chaos in Lucifer's life creates hilarious moments that effectively balance the overall drama of the show.

2. Lucifer Season 6

Lucifer ​​​​​​season 6 was somewhat chaotic. However, the intense romance between Chloe and Lucifer added an alluring touch, elevating it above previous seasons. This installment primarily revolved around Lucifer's startling discovery of another angel residing on Earth, who turns out to be none other than his and Chloe's daughter from the future, Rory. Astonishingly, Lucifer had abandoned Rory, prompting the season's focus on unraveling this mystery. While the time paradox seemed rational, it felt perplexing that, after a whole season of punishing Lucifer for his inability to traverse between Hell and Earth, his daughter could effortlessly do so whenever she pleased.

There are numerous delightful moments in this season. Lucifer genuinely cares about his daughter. He is determined to safeguard her and has no intention of forsaking her, despite the consequences of his future choices. His daughter's presence serves as a remarkable illustration of Lucifer's personal and leadership growth. The only character who is truly left behind in this situation is Trixie—Chloe's daughter—given the strong bond she had with Lucifer in previous seasons. The show could have made an effort to strike a balance between the two.

1. Lucifer Season 5

Lucifer's final season was beyond exceptional. Spanning two parts, it delved into a captivating blend of evil doppelgangers and intense love tales. The introduction of Michael as Lucifer's identical twin ingeniously added a refreshing twist to the oft-told narrative. Their subsequent race for celestial support, akin to a political campaign, shed fascinating light on the battle between good and evil in the realm of politics. The epic showdown between the two siblings served as a grand finale to Lucifer's fifth season.

During the era of Deckerstar, their bond grew stronger. The fourth season of Lucifer tested their relationship, as Chloe contemplated ending his life upon learning his true identity. However, this season showcased their journey as a genuine couple, no longer plagued by uncertainty. Both characters experienced personal growth, and Lucifer demonstrated his own development. Ultimately, he made a selfless choice by sparing his brother's life, convincing his siblings of his worthiness to be God.