Highlights
The Uchiha Massacre in Naruto underwent a retcon, revealing that Itachi had an accomplice, Obito, who played a significant role in the killings.
The retcon undermines Itachi's established strength and character, depicting him as weaker and his backstory as less profound. Despite the necessity for the retcon to enable Sasuke's discovery of the truth behind the massacre, it has a detrimental impact on Itachi's overall portrayal.
Similar to many other long-running shonen anime, the Naruto series is plagued by inconsistent elements and alterations to the story. Some changes are made to address inconsistencies within the storyline, while others are subtly incorporated to improve the overall plot coherence. In Shippuden, the tragic Uchiha Massacre underwent a similar fate as several additional details were introduced, completely altering the tone and narrative.
The Uchiha Clan massacre is undeniably the most significant event in the entire series, and any modifications to its storyline can have far-reaching consequences for the anime. Following the revelation of previously undisclosed information during Itachi and Sasuke's confrontation, fans were presented with a revised version of events that felt forced and poorly executed. These details also clashed with the previously established premise, giving the impression of a last-minute alteration.
The Uchiha Massacre’s Initial Narrative
The Uchiha Clan Massacre is a significant event in Naruto, setting a serious tone for the series from the start. Itachi Uchiha, a renegade ninja, played a central role in this massacre, betraying his clan and mercilessly killing all of his relatives, except for his younger brother. Itachi was portrayed as a highly skilled shinobi, unmatched by only a few, and his name was always associated with extraordinary achievements.
This event had a profound impact on Sasuke's character development, but it also held great importance for Itachi himself. It portrayed him as a shinobi with almost god-like abilities and motivations that were beyond anyone's understanding. However, in Shippuden, the missing pieces of this tragic event were revealed, giving fans insight into Itachi's true loyalties and the questionable decisions made by the Leaf Village. This revelation added another layer of complexity to Itachi's character, making him one of the most beloved characters in the series.
The narrative of the series remained largely intact, as much of Itachi and Sasuke's character development revolved around the aftermath of the massacre. Sasuke's purpose in life was defined by seeking revenge and defeating his brother, which fueled his thirst for power and strength. On the other hand, Itachi carried the burden of ruthlessly wiping out his entire clan for the sake of the village, or at least that's what fans initially believed.
A New Perpetrator in the Narrative
The initial account of Itachi's heinous acts on that ill-fated night remained unchanged until the decisive confrontation between Sasuke and Itachi, wherein numerous crucial details were unveiled. Among the most pivotal revelations was the existence of another Uchiha whom Itachi regarded as his accomplice. This revelation shattered the notion that Itachi had executed the annihilation of his own clan single-handedly, dispelling the false narrative he had crafted.
This information was later confirmed in a subsequent flashback, revealing that Obito, who was impersonating Madara at the time, had actually worked alongside Itachi to handle the Uchiha Clan. Contrary to popular belief, Itachi did not defeat every Uchiha Clan member on his own; instead, it was Obito who mostly eliminated the skilled Uchihas. Itachi, on the other hand, targeted the less skilled individuals such as the elderly and children, as well as his own family.
The events depicted in the flashback solidified the fact that Obito was responsible for defeating the entire Konoha Military Police Force, a formidable unit composed of some of the strongest shinobi in the clan. Obito had no personal stake in the matter, but was convinced by Itachi and his own animosity towards the Uchiha Clan. While this revelation may not directly impact the massacre itself, it diminishes Itachi's involvement and undermines not only his character but also his combat abilities.
The Reason Behind the Retcon
Content must be rewritten in a better way:
The revelation undermines the perception of Itachi as an exceptionally strong character, as it implies that he needed assistance to achieve his power. Additionally, it diminishes the depth of his backstory, as it was originally believed that Itachi single-handedly executed his entire clan and carried the burden alone. With Obito taking on a significant role in the massacre, Itachi's involvement seems minimal and insignificant.
However, the retcon was necessary in order to reveal the truth about the massacre to Sasuke. Itachi's role in keeping the truth hidden had already been established, so the author had to find an alternative means for Sasuke to discover it. Obito's involvement in the massacre ensured that Sasuke would eventually uncover the truth, making his presence a crucial element. Although the retcon adds coherence to the story, Itachi's characterization suffers as a result of this last-minute cover-up.
Naruto is available to stream on Crunchyroll.