Summary
In order to enhance a memorable scene in The Shining, a popular viral analysis video proposes the utilization of CGI. The suggested approach involves making Shelley Duvall's character, who gazes at the torrent of blood pouring out of an elevator, seem more physically connected to the flowing blood.
Twitter users expressed their discontent with the video, claiming that Stanley Kubrick deliberately crafted the film to be open to interpretation; thus, incorporating CGI would not enhance the viewer's understanding of the scene. Additionally, the proposed enhancement fails to grasp the scene's essence, as practical effects possess the same potential impact, and the main objective is to explore Wendy's psychological state rather than offer a definitive visual representation.
Content has been
An analysis video of The Shining has gone viral, aiming to enhance the film through CGI. The Shining, directed by acclaimed filmmaker Stanley Kubrick, is widely regarded as a masterpiece. Since its debut in 1980, the terrifying murders committed by Jack Torrance at the Overlook Hotel have become an iconic representation of modern horror. The movie features numerous unforgettable shots and scenes that have left a lasting impact.
In a new video, Blender Guru proposes a revamp of a particularly memorable scene using CGI. The scene in question depicts Shelley Duvall's character, Wendy, witnessing torrents of blood rushing out of an elevator. Blender Guru points out a flaw in the original scene: Duvall and the blood are not visible together in the frame. According to Blender Guru's analysis, this creates ambiguity regarding whether the blood is real or merely a product of Wendy's imagination.
The video suggests enhancing the clip by using CGI to make Duval appear closer to the blood. Subsequently, the clip gained popularity as numerous users expressed their objections on Twitter. According to @seinfelddahog, they were thoroughly irritated by this clip and planned to remain annoyed for the remainder of the day.
@EPM106 sarcastically commented, "Stanley Kubrick foolishly created ambiguity in The Shining's events," playfully mocking Blender Guru's assertion that the scene's blending of fantasy and reality justifies the use of CGI.
Echoing the sentiment, @KevinEsquire3 scolded that this uncertainty contrasts with the overall straightforwardness of the film.
Many users, including @querrellecel, also guffawed at the video’s comparison to the would-be The Shining CGI with an effect used in Ready Player One.
Why This Video Sends The Wrong Message About CGI
The Shining CGI redo has sparked a frenzy on the internet, highlighting its absurdity. Instead of authentically reproducing the scene with CGI, the video clumsily depicts a CGI cutout being engulfed by a gush of blood. While the video primarily serves as an analysis, it is challenging to comprehend the creator's intended improvements due to the hasty patchwork.
Additionally, the suggested enhancement to The Shining fails to grasp the essence of the scene and the overall potential of CGI. Although CGI can undoubtedly enhance the visual effects, practical effects can be just as powerful when skillfully executed. In the context of The Shining, the purpose of the scene is not to appear flawlessly crisp, but rather to delve into Wendy's psychological state as she experiences unexplainable terror. As sarcastically pointed out by users, The Shining intentionally maintains ambiguity, making the use of CGI ineffective in clarifying the elevator scene.