Marvel Strikes Back: Epic MCU Response to Martin Scorsese's Cinema Criticism
The MCU's brilliant response to Martin Scorsese's cinema criticism through Loki's character is a masterstroke, showcasing their cleverness and addressing the oldest MCU criticism in a subtle and thought-provoking manner
Warning: spoilers for Loki season 2, episode 2.
Summary
In Loki season 2 episode 2, Marvel skillfully addresses Scorsese's criticism of superhero movies by showcasing a clever dialogue exchange. The episode includes a character passionately defending their film as both an "elevated thriller" and a form of "cinema," indirectly countering Scorsese's claim that superhero films lack emotional depth.
Marvel acknowledges the criticism and tacitly acknowledges that while their movies are primarily for entertainment, they still fall within the realm of cinematic art and contribute to its evolution.
In response to Martin Scorsese's critique of "cinema" and the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Marvel has issued a response through Loki season 2 episode 2. The MCU's growth and expansion have positioned it as a prime example of interconnected universes and solidified its dominance in the superhero genre. While the MCU has experienced remarkable success, it has also faced detractors, including notable filmmakers such as Martin Scorsese, who has been transparent and vocal about his stance on superhero films.
Scorsese's statement about Marvel films being "not cinema" and resembling theme parks caused significant controversy, questioning the emotional and psychological depth they offer to audiences. In a subsequent interview, Scorsese acknowledged that superhero movies represent a distinct art form. However, he expressed concern about the dominance of these expansive, spectacle-driven films that could potentially overshadow other cinematic experiences. The ensuing debates on the artistic merit of superhero movies prompted a subtle and brilliant response from Marvel, cleverly woven into the fabric of Loki season 2.
How Loki Answers Scorsese's Oldest MCU Criticism
Although Loki season 2 episode 2 does not explicitly address Martin Scorsese's comments about Marvel and superhero films, it does provide a response to his criticism. In this episode, Loki (Tom Hiddleston) and Mobius (Owen Wilson) pursue Hunter X-5 (Rafael Casal) as he ventures into the Sacred Timeline to assume the identity of Brad Wolfe, a movie actor. Upon arriving in 1977, Loki and Mobius find Wolfe attending the premiere of his latest film, Zaniac, a character derived from Marvel Comics. In the original source material, Wolfe is also a film star who undergoes a transformation due to radiation from the Manhattan Project, obtaining extraordinary strength and the ability to manifest energy knives.
Brad knew where to find Sylvie, and he eventually informed Mobius and Loki of her location. The trio journeyed to Oklahoma to rendezvous with her. While Loki and Sylvie privately conversed outside the McDonald's where she now works, Mobius and Brad remained inside. Inquisitive, Mobius questioned Brad about Zaniac, remarking that the poster appeared unnerving. Brad staunchly defended his film, asserting that it is not terrifying but rather an "elevated thriller" and "cinema, thank you very much". Though brief, this statement carries weight when considering the impact of Scorsese's critique of the MCU and superhero films.
Why Loki's Scorsese Nod Is So Clever
Instead of directly addressing Scorsese or mentioning his name, the MCU found a clever and lighthearted way to respond to the criticism. In the movie, Brad defended his own work, considering Mobius only saw it as a "scary" film. It's understandable why Morbius would have a low opinion of a movie like Zaniac, where the main character is a green serial killer who targets women. This presented a perfect opportunity for Marvel to officially address Scorsese's critique without taking offense or becoming hostile. Rather, Marvel embraced the situation and subtly acknowledged that their movies are meant for entertainment while still being considered as part of the cinematic world.
Martin Scorsese is correct in his assertion that Marvel movies are designed for pure entertainment, however, this also aligns with the goals of cinema as a whole. While it is true that the MCU and superhero films have greatly influenced the box office in recent years, it is highly unlikely that they will completely overshadow other genres of cinema and monopolize all screens, which is a concern expressed by Scorsese.
New episodes of Loki are scheduled for release every Thursday at 6pm PT / 9pm ET on Disney+.
Sources: Empire, ET
