How Reacher Could've Fixed One Major Season 2 Problem

The Loyalty to Source Material

Reacher season 2, based on Lee Child's Bad Luck & Trouble, maintained loyalty to most elements from its source material. It skillfully weaved back and forth between Reacher's present and past timelines, providing new insights into the character's military background and relationships. This approach closely mirrored the original book and offered a deeper understanding of Reacher's experiences. Additionally, the portrayal of Reacher's former team members from the 110th Special Investigations Unit stayed true to the source material, avoiding excessive creative liberties. However, despite this loyalty, other elements from the show's season 2 did not entirely align with the events in the book.

reacher-tv-show-age-book-problem-fix

One notable deviation was the involvement of Dixon and O'Donnell in the story's early episodes, contrary to the original book's gradual introduction of these characters. While this change enhanced the show in some aspects, it also led to a major problem that could have been addressed differently. The show's departure from the original book's events, particularly in this regard, had significant implications for the overall narrative and character development.

Ben Ritchson as Reacher and Willa Fitzgerald as Roscoe Conklin sitting next to each other in conversation

The Impact of Setting on Character Development

Reacher season 2's New York setting marked a significant departure from the small-town setting of season 1, and this shift had a profound impact on the show's overall tone and character development. While the urban landscape of New York raised the stakes for Reacher and his team, it also diminished the groundedness and realism that made season 1 compelling. In the smaller setting of Margrave, Reacher faced unique challenges that shaped his early character development, highlighting his distinctiveness in the close-knit community. However, the shift to New York resulted in a loss of this distinctive identity and a sense of anonymity for the characters, despite Reacher's imposing stature and crime-solving methods.

Alan Ritchson as Jack Reacher talking on the phone in Reacher season 2, episode 7

Furthermore, the decision to set the show in New York instead of California, as in the original book, impacted the overall tone of Reacher season 2. California's geographical diversity and slower pace of life could have added more depth and color to the show's tone, complementing the titular character's presence and actions. This shift in setting not only affected the show's visual appeal but also had implications for the character dynamics and the portrayal of Reacher's impact on his environment. The choice of setting played a crucial role in shaping the narrative and character interactions, ultimately influencing the audience's perception of the show.

Alan Richtson as Jack Reacher in Reacher

Conclusion and Future Implications

Reacher season 2's departure from the original book's events and the choice of New York as the setting have raised critical questions about the show's direction and potential future adaptations. While the season concluded on Prime Video, the impact of these creative decisions is likely to resonate with fans and viewers, prompting discussions about the show's authenticity and adherence to its source material. The potential for future adaptations and the exploration of different settings pose intriguing possibilities for the evolution of Reacher's on-screen portrayal and the preservation of the character's essence.

Jack with Dixon and Reacher season 2 episode 6