Exploring the Heartwarming Friendship Between Hallmark's Tyler Hynes and Erin Krakow

Hallmark Tyler Hynes and Erin Krakow Sweetest Quotes About Their Friendship

Tyler Hynes and Erin Krakow Getty Images (2)

Hallmark stars Erin Krakow and Tyler Hynes have built a strong bond since starring together in the 2021 film, It Was Always You.

The movie is a romantic comedy that revolves around Krakow's character, Elizabeth, whose engagement plans are disrupted when her fiancé's brother, David (played by Hynes), returns home after teaching underprivileged children around the world. David's unexpected return causes Elizabeth to reevaluate her choices and her future in love. Ultimately, Elizabeth calls off her wedding, embarks on a year-long journey traveling the world, and finally reunites with David in a heartwarming conclusion.

The movie quickly became a favorite among fans, who have been eagerly calling for Krakow and Hynes to team up for a second film. In an exclusive interview with We in April 2024, Krakow mentioned that she has never received as many requests for a sequel as she did for It Was Always You.

Krakow expressed her excitement about the possibility of a sequel, noting that the characters in the film have a list of places they would like to visit. She mentioned her desire to act alongside Hynes once more, even if they were to portray different characters. Krakow added that working with Tyler again would be a fun experience, whether or not it involves a sequel.

Hynes shared the same feelings in that month, expressing his willingness to do a sequel if Krakow was on board. He mentioned that Erin is a close friend, and they both admire each other's work, eager to collaborate again. He added that they both find the idea of a sequel exciting and worth exploring.

Check out some of the most heartwarming quotes from Krakow and Hynes about their friendship:

A Dynamic Duo

Hynes shared his thoughts on working with Krakow in a 2021 episode of “The Hallmark” podcast, highlighting their strong working relationship. He praised Krakow's talent, emphasizing their positive collaboration on set.

Krakow has a special quality, according to Hynes. He mentioned that the actress is able to show vulnerability in a captivating manner. There is something about her ability to display vulnerability that is truly intriguing.

Hallmark Tyler Hynes and Erin Krakow Sweetest Quotes About Their Friendship 3

Courtesy of Tyler Hynes/Instagram

Keeping It Light

Krakow playfully teased Hynes about his scene preparation during an Instagram Live session. She expressed her admiration for his attention to detail, mentioning how he makes a squinty face in the mirror and runs his fingers through his hair to ensure the perfect look.

Forming Their Bond

Hynes shared how the duo first connected — and formed a friendship — after being cast in It Was Always You.

During an interview with Entertainment Tonight in February 2021, he recalled their initial interaction. He mentioned that she greeted him with a friendly "Hi" and said something nice. He also shared that he sent her a picture of his dog, jokingly saying that was the look he was going for. Fortunately, she understood the humor and responded with a GIF of herself.

Reflecting on their first meeting, he described how their connection felt effortless. He expressed how sometimes you meet someone and instantly hit it off, skipping all the small talk. He appreciated the ease and authenticity of their dynamic.

Hallmark Tyler Hynes and Erin Krakow Sweetest Quotes About Their Friendship 2

Courtesy of Tyler Hynes/Instagram

Easy Chemistry

Krakow shared during a 2021 podcast interview that she couldn't pick just one thing she enjoyed about her costar. She described their working relationship as feeling natural and comfortable, as if they had been working together for years. According to Krakow, Tyler is not only a talented actor but also a collaborative partner who is dedicated to enhancing their work together.

Let's Snack and Plan a Sequel

During an Instagram Q&A in November 2023, someone asked Krakow if she would do another movie with Hynes soon. She jokingly replied, "Only if we have key lime pie, peanut butter cake, and absolutely no oysters. What do you say, @tyler_hynes?"

Hynes, for his part wrote in the comments section, “Yes ma’am as u wish @erinkrakow.”

Ready to Team Up Again

Krakow expressed in April 2024 that there is potential for a “great” sequel to It Was Always You, but she also mentioned how enjoyable it would be to work with Hynes again. She also expressed interest in collaborating with the “cousins of Hallmark,” which includes Hynes, Paul Campbell, and Andrew Walker from Three Wisemen and a Baby.

Hynes, on the other hand, shared that both he and Krakow are eager to return for a second movie. He mentioned to Us in the same month that it would be a fun experience.

Editor's P/S:

The article highlights the undeniable chemistry and strong bond between Erin Krakow and Tyler Hynes, who starred together in the Hallmark movie "It Was Always You." The enthusiastic response from fans has sparked calls for a sequel, and both Krakow and Hynes have expressed their eagerness to reunite on screen.

Krakow has praised Hynes' talent and dedication, while Hynes has admired her authenticity and vulnerability. Their easy connection and shared passion for storytelling have created a harmonious working relationship. Beyond their onscreen chemistry, the duo shares a genuine friendship, evident in their playful interactions and mutual respect. Their camaraderie extends off-set, as they enjoy spending time together and share a love of food. The article suggests that the potential sequel to "It Was Always You" would not only fulfill the wishes of their fans but also showcase the enduring bond between these two talented actors.