One Piece is widely acclaimed as a captivating adventure, fueled by a compelling narrative filled with epic moments, exhilarating battles, and captivating storytelling. The Straw Hat Pirates, the story's main protagonists, embark on their world exploration with a lighthearted sense of humor and joyful laughter. However, amidst their carefree nature, the series also delves into darker themes.
Going beyond simply showcasing violence, One Piece presents a realistic portrayal of human cruelty. Eiichiro Oda tackles various real-life issues, including slavery, racism, senseless animosity, sadistic oppression, and other significant matters within the series.
Oda showcases the intricacies of human nature through the stark juxtaposition between the depths to which some individuals can stoop and the acts of heroism and kindness exhibited by others. Although these moments serve to enrich the franchise's elaborate worldbuilding and lore, they also have a chilling impact on fans, evoking haunting reminders of real-life tragedies. Please note that this article contains significant spoilers from the One Piece manga up to chapter 1098.
The most disturbing moments in One Piece explored in detail
10) The heinous end of Donquixote Homing
Homing, depicted in the above image by Toei Animation for the series One Piece, tragically met his demise at the hands of his own son.
In contrast to his fellow Celestial Dragons, Homing possessed a genuinely compassionate nature and harbored deep affection for his wife and son. Desiring a life void of the privileges and mistreatment exhibited by his noble peers, he made the decision to relocate his family far from the confines of Mary Geoise. Regrettably, this seemingly noble choice ultimately resulted in an unforeseen catastrophe for him.
Despite his innocence, Homing suffered the consequences of the actions committed by his former fellow Celestial Dragons. Considered nobles, like those despised for their cruel deeds, he and his family were subjected to persecution by the commoners. This led to a life of destitution, where Homing's wife tragically fell ill and passed away. Subsequently, the commoners discovered Homing and his sons, subjecting them to brutal torture. Blaming Homing for their misfortunes, one of his sons, Doflamingo, made the decision to take his life.
9) The burning of the Gray Terminal
Seeking to restore his noble standing, Doflamingo cold-bloodedly executed his father by shooting him in the back of the head. Prior to his untimely demise, Homing wore a sorrowful smile, offering his apologies to his two sons for his shortcomings as a father.
The Goa Kingdom, located on Dawn Island, has a dark history marred by inequality and cruelty. The High Town, an affluent area in the capital city of Goa, has systematically segregated and marginalized individuals from lower social classes, condemning them to a life confined to a squalid junkyard. (Image via Toei Animation, One Piece)
The area was dubbed the Gray Terminal, a lawless community where its inhabitants lacked access to proper healthcare and survived by selling goods scavenged from the slums. Luffy, Ace, and Sabo frequented this hazardous environment during their childhood.
When a Celestial Dragon planned to visit the Goa Kingdom, the ruling royal family deemed it necessary to eradicate the Gray Terminal, fearing that its existence would tarnish the nation's image. Supported by the affluent citizens, the heartless aristocracy enlisted the Bluejam Pirates to set fire to the Gray Terminal and its inhabitants.
The entire area was set ablaze by the pirates, who ruthlessly slaughtered anyone attempting to flee. Ironically, the pirates themselves perished in the same incident, as the Goa monarch sealed off the city gates, leaving them stranded outside amidst the inferno. Unfortunately, the arson claimed the lives of numerous individuals, with only a fortunate few managing to survive thanks to the assistance of the Revolutionary Army.
8) Children used as guinea pigs
The image above shows one of the kids who was experimented on by Caesar Clown in the anime series One Piece (Image via Toei Animation).
In the past, the laboratory in Punk Hazard was under the management of Vegapunk, who utilized it for conducting various experiments on behalf of the World Government. Among the subjects he experimented on were Kaido and Alber, a survivor from the Lunarian race. Eventually, the World Government decided to abandon the island, leading to Caesar Clown taking over and making it his own personal base of operations.
Caesar, a scientist who specialized in chemical weapons of mass destruction, embarked on researching gigantification. He discovered that he could induce the growth of giants by injecting significant amounts of specific substances into children, albeit at the expense of reducing their lifespan.
Despite being fully aware of the devastating consequences of his experiments, Caesar persisted in conducting them. In his quest for more subjects, he resorted to kidnapping children from their families. Upon their arrival at Punk Hazard, Caesar would deceive them into regularly ingesting NHC10.
If the children were to cease using NHC10, they would experience severe withdrawal symptoms, such as pain and hallucinations. In addition, excessive doses of the medication would result in internal harm. Despite his humorous facade, Caesar's self-centered brutality was unsettling.
7) Brook spent decades alone with the corpses of his comrades
For many decades, Brook's life was a never-ending nightmare (Image via Toei Animation, One Piece).
Years ago, Brook belonged to the adventurous Rumbar Pirates. In a fierce confrontation, Brook and his fellow crew members suffered dreadful injuries from contaminated weaponry. With the realization that they were all doomed to succumb to the lethal poison, Brook beseeched his comrades to harmonize one final melody together. This heartfelt performance would be immortalized on a Tone Dial.
Brook, equipped with the Revive-Revive Fruit, had the power to come back to life even after death. Using this ability, he revived himself and carried the Tone Dial along with him to their loyal friend, Laboon the whale. In a bittersweet moment, the Rumbar Pirates played their beloved song, "Binks's Sake," for the last time as they slowly succumbed to their fates, one by one.
Thanks to his extraordinary Devil Fruit power, Brook experienced a miraculous resurrection. However, due to the unfortunate circumstances, his soul only managed to locate his skeletal remains, leaving him as a revived skeleton. Stuck in the eerie Florian Triangle, Brook endured decades of torment and misery as he mourned the tragic destiny of his fellow crewmates.
Until the Straw Hat Pirates arrived, Brook endured a harrowing existence that could only be described as on the brink of madness. Stranded on the ship, at the mercy of the unpredictable ocean currents, he was surrounded by the lifeless bodies of his fallen comrades.
6) Big Mom's cannibalism
Toei Animation's One Piece showcases the eerie actions of Big Mom (Image via Toei Animation, One Piece).
Originally known as Charlotte Linlin, she was one of the children raised by Mother Carmel. However, Linlin's innate and extraordinary strength proved to be unsettling, leading Carmel to plan her sale to the World Government. Abandoned and devoid of moral guidance, Linlin developed numerous personality disorders throughout her tumultuous upbringing.
She was often seen engaging in acts of both childlike and incredibly vicious cruelty. However, one day, Linlin's lack of self-control led to a disturbing and bizarre incident. Overwhelmed by an insatiable hunger, she devoured Carmel and the rest of the orphans.
Although there were no explicit visuals, the horrific truth of what transpired became apparent. As Linlin consumed the food voraciously, Carmel and the other orphans were in close proximity. By the time she finished her feast, they had mysteriously vanished. At the same time, Linlin gained the extraordinary powers bestowed by Carmel's Soul-Soul Fruit.
5) The slave trade
One Piece fans are still incredulous at the genuinely horrifying moment caused by Big Mom's morbid obsession for food, which is another clue to what happened as Devil Fruits respawn near where their previous users died. Eating disorders can be unhealthy.
The practice of slavery is utterly repugnant, whereby one person is treated as mere property at the hands of another. It is regarded as one of the most abhorrent crimes against humanity. Even within the realm of fiction, such as in One Piece, slavery is strictly forbidden.
In contrast, the Celestial Dragons engage in a continuous pattern of enslavement, offering bribes to both the Navy and the World Government as a means to secure surrender. This enslavement extends to a wide range of individuals, including civilians, imprisoned pirates, outlaws, and even those belonging to rare races, as the nobles hold the authority to select anyone they desire for servitude.
Those subjected to enslavement bear a distinctive mark that cruelly reinforces their status as inferior to ordinary humans. To make matters worse, it is truly alarming to learn that the Marines actively pursue and apprehend any enslaved individual who dares to seek liberation.
Enslaved individuals are compelled to don a collar equipped with a chain that, if severed, triggers the collar to detonate. Celestial Dragons routinely engage in the trading, tormenting, and murder of these vulnerable captives at their own discretion. While in Sabaody, the Straw Hats were exposed to a distressing and perplexing sight—an auction where enslaved individuals were being bought and sold.
4) The massacre of Flevance
The events that unfolded in Flevance are tragically true to life (Image via Toei Animation, One Piece).
Flevance, a nation situated in North Blue, thrived economically by extracting Amber Lead. Despite being aware of the mineral's toxic nature, both the World Government and Flevance's royal family opted to withhold this information from the populace in order to maintain their profits. As a result, numerous residents suffered from severe illnesses and succumbed to death.
The royal family departed the kingdom as they could no longer bear witness to the catastrophe. In fear of the disease's contagious nature, neighboring nations imposed a quarantine on Flevance. In an effort to eliminate any potential risk of spreading, they mercilessly chose to exterminate all the inhabitants.
Amber Lead Syndrome, an inherited condition, is not contagious and is primarily caused by prolonged exposure to minerals. Despite being aware of this fact, the World Government chose to withhold the truth, even at the cost of countless lives in Flevance.
Out of an unfounded bias, numerous individuals were killed, including Trafalgar Law's parents and younger sister. Law, who was just a child at the time, managed to avoid the slaughter by concealing himself beneath a heap of bodies. Understandably traumatized, he adopted a nihilistic demeanor, which he only relinquished upon encountering Donquixote Rosinante.
3) The Native Hunting Tournament
The nobles orchestrated plans to execute a staggering 100,000 individuals within the confines of God Valley (Image via Toei Animation, One Piece).
The disregard that the Celestial Dragons possess for the sanctity of human life is so astonishing that they have gone as far as carrying out acts of genocide purely for their own amusement. Handpicking a nation that had no affiliations with the World Government, they maliciously orchestrated a human hunting event, wherein their slaves and the innocent residents of the host land became unwilling participants.
The Celestial Dragons participating in the hunt received varying points for each human target they eliminated, referred to as "rabbits." This contest, characterized by its absurdity, has been held every three years for an unknown duration, always culminating in a complete absence of survivors.
Driven by a twisted sense of superiority, the Celestial Dragons ruthlessly massacred countless individuals without a shred of conscience. Disregarding the value of human life, they vied against one another, striving to claim the highest number of "rabbit" kills.
In order to make the game more exciting and encourage the "rabbits" to give their utmost effort, the Celestial Dragon employs deceit by promising them freedom if they can survive for three weeks.
God Valley was chosen as the site for the Native Hunting Tournament thirty-eight years ago, with the Celestial Dragons aiming to exterminate approximately 100,000 "rabbits" on the island. Despite the rightful king's attempts to discourage the nobles from their cruel plan, he was swiftly assassinated by Saint Figarland Garling.
2) The death of Kuma's parents
Kuma's family was destroyed by a rotten political system (Image via Toei Animation, One Piece)
The flashback featuring Bartholomew Kuma in One Piece delves into a level of darkness seldom explored before, resembling elements typically found in seinen series. Kuma's birth initially brought warmth and affection from his loving parents, unaware of the impending tragedy that awaited them due to a corrupt system.
Once Kuma's father, a person named Clapp, was exposed as a member of the Buccaneer race, the World Government dispatched agents to apprehend him, his wife, and their son. Subsequently, their lives were irrevocably shattered as a series of tragic events unfolded.
Kuma's mother perished under difficult circumstances, leaving his father, Clapp, with the painful realization that her suffering had finally ended. Determined to instill faith in his son, Clapp recounted the tale of Nika, the revered "Sun God" believed to bring liberation to the oppressed.
In a chilling twist of fate, just as Clapp imitated the rhythmic gestures of Nika's "Drums of Liberation," a majestic Celestial Dragon abruptly snuffed out his life. The sight was shocking, with Kuma initially donning a smile upon hearing about Nika's legend, only to be suddenly ensnared in the tragic aftermath, drenched in his father's crimson blood.
The situation became even more horrifying as Clapp was mercilessly killed by the Celestial Dragon for the sole reason that he had made too much noise while trying to uplift his son's spirits. This cruel act of the noble showed a complete lack of remorse or hesitation. Truly, it was unimaginably heartless. The chapter in question aptly bears the title "Better off dead in this world."
1) Ginny's horrific fate brings One Piece close to a seinen
Ginny's account was uniquely unsettling even within the extraordinary standards of One Piece (Image via Toei Animation, One Piece).
Ginny emerged as a vocal and astute young girl who, alongside Ivankov and Kuma, played a crucial role in the perilous Human Hunting Tournament of God Valley. With a combination of cleverness and determination, the trio managed to survive the tumultuous event. Eventually finding their place in Sorbet, Ginny and Kuma eventually became members of the Revolutionary Army.
Unfortunately, Ginny fell victim to abduction by a Celestial Dragon, who compelled her into marriage. After two years, the noble set her free, fearing that she had contracted a deadly illness that he did not wish to catch.
Just moments before her demise, Ginny successfully reached out to Kuma, but by the time he arrived, she had already passed away. By her side lay Bonney, a one-year-old child strongly suggesting that she was the result of Ginny's forced marriage.
Similar situations have been depicted in One Piece before, but never in such a glaring manner. Even in Ginny's case, there was no direct portrayal or statement, yet the underlying implication was unmistakable. Considering the well-known malevolence of nobles, it was not surprising but indeed heart-wrenching.
Ginny's life in Sorbet alongside Kuma was a fleeting period of joy, mercilessly crushed by savage brutality. When exposing her mistreatment and eventual demise, Oda purposely omitted Ginny's face, emphasizing her complete dehumanization as a disposable object, used and discarded. This particular moment in One Piece was unusually somber compared to its usual standards.
Keep up with One Piece manga, anime, and live-action as 2023 progresses.
Editor's P/S
One Piece is a captivating adventure, fueled by a compelling narrative filled with epic moments, exhilarating battles, and captivating storytelling. However, amidst their carefree nature, the series also delves into darker themes. Eiichiro Oda tackles various real-life issues, including slavery, racism, senseless animosity, sadistic oppression, and other significant matters within the series.
The Goa Kingdom, located on Dawn Island, has a dark history marred by inequality and cruelty. The High Town, an affluent area in the capital city of Goa, has systematically segregated and marginalized individuals from lower social classes, condemning them to a life confined to a squalid junkyard. The area was dubbed the Gray Terminal, a lawless community where its inhabitants lacked access to proper healthcare and survived by selling goods scavenged from the slums. Luffy, Ace, and Sabo frequented this hazardous environment during their childhood.