Doctor Who's Season 14: A Fresh Start or a Misguided Attempt?

Doctor Who's Season 14: A Major Reset?

The recent marketing material for Doctor Who's Season 14 has sparked a debate within the Whovian community. The decision to label Ncuti Gatwa's debut as the Doctor as 'Season One' has raised eyebrows and ignited speculation about the future direction of the iconic series. This unconventional move not only hints at a significant reset but also sheds light on the show's perceived shortcomings.

Varada Sathu and Ncuti Gatwa back to back

The revival of Doctor Who has seen the stewardship of Russell T Davies, Steven Moffat, and Chris Chibnall, each leaving their distinct imprint on the series. With RTD's return as the head writer, the show enters a new era, marking a departure from the Moffat and Chibnall eras. While the show has evolved in tone and style over the years, the explicit 'Season One' label seems to suggest a radical departure from the established narrative, a leap that may be too ambitious even for a show known for its regeneration.

Chris Chibnall and Russell T Davies with Ncuti Gatwa as Fifteenth Doctor in Doctor Who

Reimagining the Doctor's Legacy

The decision to brand Season 14 as 'Season One' raises questions about the intended narrative direction. Rather than signaling a continuation of the established character arcs and themes, this choice presents the possibility of a complete narrative reset. However, this approach is met with skepticism for several reasons.

A custom image of Ncuti Gatwa as the Fifteenth Doctor and Christopher Eccleston as the Ninth Doctor against a blended backdrop of Doctor Who scenery

Firstly, the proximity of Ncuti Gatwa's portrayal to David Tennant's latest appearance places him firmly within the tradition of the revival era, rather than as a wholly distinct entity. The rich history and mythology of the show, spanning 19 years, are deeply intertwined with Gatwa's Doctor, making a 'Season One' narrative difficult to justify. Furthermore, the practical implications of disregarding the show's established lore and the potential disappointment of fans add to the complexity of this bold narrative shift.

Ruby, Fifteenth Doctor and the Goblin King in Doctor Who

Secondly, the show's attempt to create a new era through elaborate plot devices, such as bi-generation, raises concerns about rewriting the established conventions and undermining the impact of earlier stories. While the desire to infuse freshness into the series is understandable, it must be balanced with respect for the show's rich legacy and the rules that have made it a beloved cultural phenomenon.

This collage shows Ruby Sunday and the Doctor from Doctor Who in front of the stars.

Navigating the Canon and the Future

The concept of a third 'Season One' raises both narrative and logistical challenges for Doctor Who. The series already has two distinct season 1s, from 1963 and 2005, each marking significant milestones in the show's history. Introducing a third season 1 in 2024 not only presents a logistical conundrum but also raises questions about the show's evolving canon and timeline.

Ncuti Gatwa as the Fifteenth Doctor looking up next to an image of the Fifteenth Doctor smiling on Doctor Who

Unlike the 2005 revival, the current iteration of Doctor Who is firmly established as a global brand, cherished by millions worldwide. This begs the question: What justifies a 'Season One'-style reset in 2024? While the return of familiar characters hints at continuity, the decision to label Season 14 as 'Season One' remains enigmatic and invites speculation about the show's future trajectory.

The Fifteenth Doctor looks upset while talking to the Fourteenth Doctor in the TARDIS in Doctor Who.