Doctor Who Showrunner RTD Compares David Tennant's 10th & 14th Doctors: Exploring the Differences

Article Overview

According to Doctor Who showrunner Russell T Davies, the return of David Tennant as the Fourteenth Doctor will not result in any significant personality alterations. However, it will introduce fresh twists and added layers to the character.

The return of the previous creative team might cause viewers to worry about the show relying on nostalgia. However, Tennant's acknowledgement of the passage of time ensures a convincing depiction of the Fourteenth Doctor's age and development. While Tennant's portrayal of the Tenth Doctor was widely recognized and referenced, his comeback will bring a harmonious blend and improve his portrayal of the Fourteenth Doctor.

Doctor Who showrunner Russell T Davies discusses the differences between David Tennant's Tenth Doctor and Fourteenth Doctor prior to his 60th-anniversary comeback. Tennant originally played the tenth version of the Time Lord from 2005 to 2009 and then reprised the role in the 2013 special "The Day of the Doctor." In November and December, three celebratory episodes featuring Tennant and returning companion Catherine Tate will be broadcast, starting with "The Star Beast" on November 25.

Ahead of Tennant's imminent return for Doctor Who's 60th anniversary, Davies spoke with SFX Magazine about how the actor has made sure that this new incarnation of the Doctor stands apart from previous versions. While Davies cautioned against expecting a dramatic change in personality, he affirmed that Tennant effectively portrayed the distinctions through his performance. See Davies' complete explanation below:

I would not anticipate significant differences, as there is no way that you can bring back one of the most beloved Doctors in the world and make him completely different! Outside of the fanbase, my sisters would be sitting there asking, 'What on earth have you done?'

So it doesn't really make much sense. But, of course, we are talking about one of the world's finest actors who does not require me to provide lines, cues, subtext, or meanings. You simply hand the script to David, and naturally, he excels at it. He brings new perspectives and depths to the character effortlessly. When you have the privilege of working with someone like that, there is no need to worry.

How David Tennant Prepared To Portray The Fourteenth Doctor Different From The Tenth Doctor

While Tennant's return as the Doctor aligns with viewer expectations for Doctor Who's anniversary storylines, there is concern about the implications it holds for the future of the long-standing British show. With Davies reuniting with producers Julie Gardner, Jane Tranter, Phil Collinson, and composer Murray Gold, who were instrumental in the successful 2005 revival, there is a sense of nostalgia-driven decision-making that might be employed to attract audiences for the 60th-anniversary specials and Doctor Who season 14.

Nonetheless, Tennant took it upon himself to acknowledge the passage of time between the Tenth and Fourteenth Doctors. In a recent interview, the seasoned actor revealed that he took into account the events that transpired in seasons 5 to 13 as he developed his portrayal of the Fourteenth Doctor. Tennant stated that the Doctor had experienced three different lives, each with their own meaningful impact. This reassurance suggests that the Fourteenth Doctor will embody the wisdom and maturity befitting his age, rather than mirroring the youthful persona of the Doctor when the show first began.

The video tag is not supported by your browser.

Having previously played a significant role in the show's success, actor Tennant's portrayal of the Tenth Doctor became incredibly popular and influential. As Tennant's return sparks speculation and uncertainty about his future reprisal as a Time Lord, Davis clears up any confusion by indicating how the Fourteenth Doctor will be portrayed. Tennant's careful attention to past versions of the Doctor will notably contribute to his performance as the Fourth Doctor, ultimately bringing satisfaction to Doctor Who fans.

The 60th Anniversary specials of Doctor Who will be released on Disney+ from November 25th, catering to international viewers. UK viewers can catch the new episodes on BBC One and the BBC iPlayer.

Editor's P/S

As a passionate fan of Doctor Who, I am thrilled to see David Tennant return as the Fourteenth Doctor. His portrayal of the Tenth Doctor was iconic and beloved, and I am excited to see what he brings to the role this time around.

Showrunner Russell T Davies has said that Tennant's return will not result in any significant personality alterations, but that it will introduce fresh twists and added layers to the character. I think this is a wise approach, as it will allow Tennant to bring his own unique take to the role while still staying true to the character that fans know and love.

I am also reassured by the fact that Tennant has taken into account the events that transpired in seasons 5 to 13 as he developed his portrayal of the Fourteenth Doctor. This suggests that the Fourteenth Doctor will embody the wisdom and maturity befitting his age, rather than mirroring the youthful persona of the Doctor when the show first began.

Overall, I am very excited for David Tennant's return as the Doctor. I think he will bring a fresh and exciting energy to the role, and I can't wait to see what he does with it.