Doctor Who: Ranking David Tennant's Top 10 Performances as The Doctor

Article Overview

David Tennant's portrayal of the Doctor in Doctor Who is considered the best of the "new" Doctors, and he played the role the longest in the modern era.

Tennant received critical acclaim for his exceptional performances in several episodes, notably the 50th-anniversary special "The Day of the Doctor," "The Girl in the Fireplace," "The Impossible Planet and The Satan Pit," "Midnight," "The Stolen Earth and Journeys End," "Human Nature and The Family of Blood," "Doomsday," and "The End Of Time Parts 1 and 2." His acting was highly regarded for its emotional depth, impressive range, moments of humor, and skill in building intense dramatic tension.

Ever since its reboot in 2005, Doctor Who has captivated a new generation of viewers worldwide, with the stellar performance of David Tennant being a highlight of the show. Tennant portrayed the Tenth incarnation of the Doctor from 2006 to 2010, and also made a notable appearance in the 50th-anniversary special "The Day of the Doctor". Excitingly, he is set to portray the Fourteenth Doctor in the Doctor Who 60th-anniversary special, which will feature three highly anticipated specials airing in November 2023.

Regarded as one of the best "new" Doctors, Tennant holds the record for the longest tenure in the modern era. He has appeared in a total of fifty episodes, including a brief return in "The Power of the Doctor", marking his first reappearance in the series in ten years. Despite his illustrious career in both the UK and the US, Tennant's portrayal of the iconic Time Lord remains one of his most memorable roles. While his performance throughout his time on Doctor Who was incredible, there are certain episodes that particularly stand out.

10. The Day of the Doctor

Doctor Who 50th Anniversary Special

In Doctor Who's 50th-anniversary special, "The Day of the Doctor," Tennant's Doctor crossed paths with the Eleventh Doctor (Matt Smith) and the newly introduced War Doctor (John Hurt). This marked Tennant's first appearance since leaving the show in 2010. Additionally, Billie Piper made a return as the Moment, which had transformed into the character Bad Wolf to appeal to the Doctor. The episode showcased Tennant's more lighthearted portrayal of the Time Lord, along with some humorous moments between him and his successor. At the end of "The Power of the Doctor," it was revealed that David Tennant would be returning to Doctor Who as the Fourteenth Doctor.

9. The Girl in the Fireplace

Doctor Who Season 2, Episode 4

Tennant's early portrayal of the Doctor in "The Girl in the Fireplace" showcased his talent as the new actor for the iconic role. In this episode, the Time Lord and Rose (Piper) faced off against a group of Clockwork Droids in eighteenth-century France. A notable aspect of this episode was Tennant's on-screen chemistry with Sophia Myles, who portrayed the historical figure Madam de Pompadour. Their connection translated off-screen as well, as they formed a brief relationship during filming. The emotional storyline of this Doctor Who season 2 episode received praise, enhanced by the inclusion of humorous moments skillfully delivered by Tennant.

8. The Impossible Planet and The Satan Pit

Doctor Who Season 2, Episodes 8 and 9

In Doctor Who season 2, the Ood, an alien species devoted to serving humans, made their debut. This two-part episode showcased David Tennant's captivating performance as the Doctor, who faced off against the Beast, a manifestation of evil lurking in an unfathomable abyss. The story masterfully explored the evolving bond between the Doctor and Rose, culminating in a powerful and unforgettable moment as Tennant delivered a remarkable monologue in the depths of the pit.

7. Midnight

Doctor Who Season 4, Episode 10

"Midnight" is widely regarded as one of the finest Doctor Who episodes featuring a reduced number of companions. In this particular installment, the Doctor finds himself stranded on an excursion while visiting the planet Midnight, a fascinating world adorned in shimmering diamonds. The primary antagonist of this episode takes on an ethereal form, constantly shifting between the Doctor and Sky Silvestry (Lesley Sharp). Tennant's performance in "Midnight" was acclaimed for his impeccable synchronization with Sharp, while also delivering a captivating sense of dramatic tension. This episode brilliantly highlights Tennant's talents, resulting in an enthralling, unexpected, and enjoyable viewing experience.

6. The Stolen Earth and Journeys End

Doctor Who Season 4, Episode 13

Upon its release, the two-part finale of Doctor Who season 4 proved to be a resounding success. This highly-anticipated event marked the return of multiple companions, the introduction of the Doctor Donna, and the heart-wrenching departure of Donna Noble (played by Catherine Tate) from the TARDIS. Infused with a multitude of emotional highs and lows, the final moments of this narrative showcased one of Tennant's most poignant performances as he reluctantly returned Donna to her family, erasing her memories in the process. This dramatic conclusion laid the groundwork for Tennant's final episodes, in which the Tenth Doctor found himself without a companion for the third time.

5. Human Nature and The Family of Blood

Doctor Who Season 3, Episodes 8 and 9

In an attempt to protect himself from a group of aliens who were seeking to steal his Time Lord life essence, the Doctor disguised himself as a human and went into hiding on Earth in 1913. This two-part episode from season 3 showcases Tennant's exceptional talent and versatility as he portrays a human character who remains unaware of his true identity as a Time Lord. These episodes are filled with suspense and ambiguity, pushing Tennant to explore new dimensions in his performance. Moreover, the poignant moments between the Doctor and Joan Redfern (played by Jessica Hynes) delve into deep emotions as John Smith realizes that he cannot lead a human life with her.

4. Doomsday

Doctor Who Season 2, Episode 13

The TARDIS bid a tearful farewell to Rose Tyler in the heart-wrenching season 2 finale of Doctor Who, aptly titled "Doomsday". Viewers were left in awe as the Doctor experienced immense heartbreak when he parted ways with his beloved human companion, who was forever trapped in a parallel universe. David Tennant's exceptional portrayal of the Time Lord in his first season finale received widespread acclaim for its gripping emotional depth and thrilling entertainment value.

3. The End Of Time Parts 1 and 2

2009 Specials

Tennant's tenure as the Doctor came to an end with "The End Of Time," where he once again faced off against John Simm's Master before passing on the role to Matt Smith. The Doctor Who specials leading up to Tennant's departure are widely regarded as some of his finest performances, but his ultimate chapter as the Time Lord shines brightly among them. Bid farewell to Wilfred Mott (Bernard Cribbins), this Doctor was devastated by his impending regeneration, and his final moments were woven with a heart-wrenching last line: "I don't want to go."

2. The Waters of Mars

2009 Specials

"The Waters of Mars" marked Tennant's second-to-last portrayal of the Doctor and is often regarded as the most chilling episode in the Doctor Who series. In this episode, the Doctor encounters the residents of Bowie Base One and comes face-to-face with The Flood, a mysterious extraterrestrial entity inhabiting the dark corners of Mars. Despite knowing that the impending deaths of the human colonists are fixed in time, the Doctor resolves to rescue them. As the situation escalates, the Doctor loses control and unleashes his fury upon the universe, boldly declaring, "The laws of time are mine to command!"

1. Last of the Time Lords

Doctor Who Season 3, Episode 13

In "Last of the Time Lords," the third and final arc of Doctor Who season 3 comes to an end as Martha Jones (Freema Aygeman) successfully topples the rule of the Master (John Simm) over Earth. Trapped by his long-time adversary for over a year, the Doctor (played by David Tennant) showcases a gripping and thrilling performance, even while predominantly in CGI form. Once restored to his true self, Tennant delivers a heart-wrenching moment that is arguably his finest display in the entire series. Emotionally pleading with the Master, the Doctor implores him not to embrace his own demise, desperately hoping to avoid being the last of their kind.

Editor's P/S

As an enthusiastic fan of Doctor Who, I am thrilled to see David Tennant's return to the role of the Doctor for the show's 60th anniversary. His portrayal of the Tenth Doctor was truly exceptional, and I believe he is one of the best actors to have played the role.

Tennant's acting range and emotional depth brought a new level of intensity to the character, and his chemistry with his companions, particularly Rose Tyler and Donna Noble, was electric. Some of my favorite episodes from his era include "The Girl in the Fireplace," "Blink," and "The End of Time." I am eagerly anticipating his return to the role and can't wait to see what new adventures and challenges he will face.