Controversy Surrounding Kate's Edited Photo Sparks New Speculation

The image of a smiling Catherine, Princess of Wales, with her three children was meant to quiet speculation about her health and whereabouts. However, it only led to a new controversy for the royal family. Multiple global news agencies pulled the image from circulation due to concerns of manipulation.

Kensington Palace released the photograph early Sunday on the couple's official social media accounts to celebrate Mother's Day in the United Kingdom. Following standard practice for UK royal photographs, it was also distributed to news and photo agencies for wider release.

Kate was pictured with Prince George, Princess Charlotte, and Prince Louis, looking relaxed and laughing. The photo was credited to Prince William, who may have sparked the joyful moment.

After the storm passed on Monday morning, Kate issued a personal apology. She took responsibility for the confusion that she had unintentionally caused.

I enjoy trying out editing as an amateur photographer. I wanted to apologize for any confusion caused by the family photo we shared yesterday. I hope everyone had a wonderful Mother's Day celebration. She signed off her post with a "C" for Catherine.

This undated photo issued on Sunday, March 10, 2024, by Kensington Palace shows Kate, Princess of Wales, with her children, Prince Louis, left, Prince George and Princess Charlotte. The circled areas appear to show evidence of potential manipulation.

This photo, released by Kensington Palace on Sunday, March 10, 2024, shows Kate, Princess of Wales, with her children - Prince Louis, Prince George, and Princess Charlotte. In the image, some areas appear to have been possibly altered.

The family celebrates the occasion annually, but the heartfelt photo was also viewed as a reassuring message to the public, possibly alleviating worries after Kate's surgery earlier in the year for a noncancerous abdominal problem.

Even though the palace had mentioned that it would take a couple of months for the princess to fully recuperate, her temporary break from public appearances and the ambiguity surrounding her health led to speculation on social media, with various conspiracy theories circulating from the insensitive to the downright bizarre.

This year’s Mother’s Day photograph was the first time we saw the princess since Christmas Day. Last week, a blurry paparazzi picture surfaced of Kate sitting in the front seat of a car driven by her mother. CNN and other news outlets chose not to publish this unauthorized photo, as reputable organizations usually refrain from using paparazzi images without a valid editorial reason or public interest justification.

GREAT ABACO, BAHAMAS - MARCH 26: Prince William, Duke of Cambridge and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge during a visit to Daystar Evangelical Church on March 26, 2022 in Great Abaco, Bahamas. Abaco was dramatically hit by Hurricane Dorian, It damaged 75% of homes across the chain of islands and resulted in tragic loss of life. During their visit to the Church they will hear first-hand what it was like to be on the island at the point the hurricane hit, and how people have come together to support each other during an incredibly difficult time. The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are visiting Belize, Jamaica and The Bahamas on behalf of Her Majesty The Queen on the occasion of the Platinum Jubilee. The 8 day tour takes place between Saturday 19th March and Saturday 26th March and is their first joint official overseas tour since the onset of COVID-19 in 2020. (Photo by Chris Jackson/Getty Images)

Prince William, Duke of Cambridge, and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge visited Daystar Evangelical Church on March 26, 2022 in Great Abaco, Bahamas. The island was severely affected by Hurricane Dorian, resulting in 75% of homes being damaged and tragic loss of life. During their visit to the church, they listened to firsthand accounts of the hurricane's impact and how the community came together to support each other during this challenging time.

The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are on a tour of Belize, Jamaica, and The Bahamas on behalf of Her Majesty The Queen to celebrate the Platinum Jubilee. This 8-day tour, taking place from Saturday, March 19th to Saturday, March 26th, marks their first official overseas visit together since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.

Related article

Why the royals have become the center of conspiracy theories

Questions started circulating on social media regarding the Mother's Day image featuring the princess. People closely examined every detail, including the absence of her wedding or engagement ring and the lush green background despite the cold March weather.

The discussion intensified when The Associated Press retracted the image and indicated that it may have been manipulated by the source. This led to other news agencies also advising caution when sharing the image.

An initial review by CNN found two areas in the image that may have been manipulated: the sleeve cuff of Princess Charlotte and the zipper on the left side of the Princess of Wales' jacket, which seems misaligned.

CNN has chosen to keep using the original photo with a suitable caption amid discussions about its possible manipulation.

Catherine, Princess of Wales, pictured in 2023, had abdominal surgery in January that has sidelined her for several months.

This area around the sleeve of Princess Charlotte appears to show evidence of potential manipulation.

Kensington Palace

This area on the jacket of Catherine, Princess of Wales, appears to show a misaligned break along the zipper.

Kensington Palace

The family photo made headlines in British newspapers on Monday. Some papers focused on the palace withdrawing the photo and the growing questions for the palace.

The Daily Telegraph's headline stated: "Photo from palace was doctored, says agencies." Meanwhile, the Daily Mail's headline asked: "This joyous Mother's Day snap was meant to be the reassurance we all needed - but has it backfired?"

Catherine, Princess of Wales, pictured in 2023, had abdominal surgery in January that has sidelined her for several months.

Kin Cheung/Getty Images

Related article

There is still uncertainty about when the Princess of Wales will make her next public appearance.

It is common for the royal family to personally take photos. Kate, in particular, is a talented photographer who has shared many family moments and milestones of her children over the years. Sometimes, they also hire photographers to take official portraits.

Palace aides are aware of the rumors surrounding the princess and have taken steps to address them while also respecting her privacy. They are trying to protect the medical privacy of one of the senior members of the Windsor family.

Kate has been recovering at the family's Adelaide Cottage in Windsor. With her recovery expected to last until at least Easter, it would make sense for William to have celebrated this year's Mother's Day in a private manner instead of inviting a professional photographer to their home.

Kate may have had a tough time getting all three young children to look at the camera at once. This could be why the explanation was a bit off in the photograph.

However, it's important to note that the image was shared for editorial reasons, and media outlets require accuracy in the images they use.

CNN is currently going through all the photos given by Kensington Palace.

In editorial photography, it is common for photojournalists and editors to make adjustments to a photo's exposure or color balance to better capture the scene. However, most news organizations, like CNN, believe that altering the pixels of an image is not okay. This would change the reality of the situation that the image is supposed to portray.

SIGN UP FOR OUR FREE ROYAL NEWSLETTER

• Stay in the loop with CNN’s Royal News, a weekly newsletter that gives you exclusive insights into the royal family, their public engagements, and the latest buzz from inside the palace walls.

In the past, the family's amateur photographs have always been well received on social media. However, this time, the photo was also shared with media organizations without transparency about any adjustments made to it.

This lack of transparency may have damaged the trust between the palace and media organizations, such as CNN, which will now likely scrutinize all royal handouts more closely. The controversy over the edited photo has weakened the current relationship, and as public interest in any potential cover-up grows, news outlets will be more inclined to take such speculation seriously.

The annual Commonwealth Day celebration at Westminster Abbey, which was scheduled to be attended by Prince William and other senior royals later on Monday, has also been affected by the situation, creating an uneasy shadow.

Some may find it difficult to accept the altered image and explanation provided by the princess, despite her apology and assertion of an honest mistake, which may help in reducing further social media discussions.

Editor's P/S:

The recent controversy surrounding the edited Mother's Day photograph of Catherine, Princess of Wales, has exposed a deeper issue of trust and transparency between the royal family and the media. The lack of upfront disclosure about image alterations has damaged the credibility of the palace and raised questions about the authenticity of future royal handouts. News organizations, including CNN, are now likely to scrutinize royal images more closely, potentially straining the relationship between the two parties.

The incident has also highlighted the challenges faced by the royal family in navigating the modern media landscape, where social media speculation and public scrutiny can amplify even minor issues. The palace's attempt to quell rumors about the princess's health with an edited image backfired, leading to further criticism and undermining their efforts to protect her privacy. This controversy serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between the royal family's desire for privacy and the public's right to accurate information about their lives.