Comparing the Ineptitude: Assessing TNG's Nova Squadron vs DS9's Red Squad

Article Overview

Both Nova Squadron and Red Squad were esteemed factions composed of Starfleet Academy trainees. Nonetheless, Red Squad's conduct was notably more reprehensible, leading to a greater number of casualties.

While Nova Squadron, headed by Nick Locarno, made a regrettable error during a maneuver, they ultimately assumed accountability and safeguarded their team. Conversely, under the guidance of Tim Watters, Red Squad made impulsive choices that resulted in the loss of their entire crew.

Red Squad's decision to engage a Jem'Hadar battleship during the Dominion War proved to be a far riskier endeavor, leading to a greater loss of life compared to the dangerous mistake made by Nova Squadron.

Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: Deep Space Nine introduced their own distinguished groups of Starfleet Academy students, namely Nova Squadron and Red Squad, each with their own penchants for trouble. Nova Squadron, consisting of the Academy's most skilled pilots, would impress audiences with their remarkable aerial displays. However, a tragic accident during a routine training exercise would forever tarnish Nova Squadron's reputation, specifically during a critical moment in the journey of Starfleet Academy Cadet Wesley Crusher (Wil Wheaton).

Star Trek: TNG’s Nova Squadron Explained

Cadet Nog, played by Aaron Eisenberg, became Wesley Crusher's unexpected successor and found himself associated with a distinguished group of Starfleet Academy students. Nog's aspirations came to fruition when he and Jake Sisko, portrayed by Cirroc Lofton, joined the crew of the USS Valiant, and the Ferengi cadet was enlisted into the prestigious team. Nonetheless, Nog should have given more consideration to the actions of Red Squad, which occurred a year or two earlier during the Changeling infiltration on Earth. Both Nova Squadron and Red Squad were led by conceited young men yearning to establish their reputations. Regrettably, both Nicholas Locarno, portrayed by Robert Duncan McNeill, and Cadet Tim Watters, played by Paul Popowich, achieved notoriety at the expense of innocent lives.

Nova Squadron was a group of highly skilled pilots at Starfleet Academy, led by the charismatic but self-centered Nick Locarno. In their quest to become legendary graduates and secure the best assignments, Locarno proposed that they perform the challenging and potentially deadly Kolvoord Starburst maneuver. This maneuver required each of the five squadron members to ignite their plasma trails while flying in perfect synchrony. However, a single mistake could result in the entire squadron losing their lives. Unfortunately, tragedy struck during a practice session over Titan when the ships collided, leading to the death of Cadet Joshua Albert.

Instead of confessing to their actions and facing the consequences, Locarno persuaded the other members of Nova Squadron to cover up the incident by falsely claiming they were attempting a different maneuver called the Yeager Loop. Captain Jean-Luc Picard, using his astute deduction skills, uncovered the truth behind the accident and encouraged Wesley Crusher to come forward and reveal what truly happened. In order to shield the remaining members of Nova Squadron, Locarno left Starfleet Academy in disgrace. Later on, Wesley Crusher acknowledged that despite Locarno's reckless behavior, he had demonstrated loyalty by accepting full responsibility so that his squadmates could pursue their Starfleet careers without hindrance.

Nick Locarno was also at Starfleet Academy with Star Trek: Lower Decks' Beckett Mariner, who later defeated his plans to use a stolen Genesis Device in the season 4 finale.

Star Trek: DS9’s Red Squad Explained

Red Squad was a respected group of Starfleet Academy Cadets who received additional training and field experience. They were first introduced in the "Homefront" episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine's fourth season. In this episode, Captain Benjamin Sisko took temporary command of Starfleet Security to address the threat posed by the Changelings. At the same time, Admiral Leyton orchestrated a military coup with the help of Red Squad, disabling the global power distribution center and framing the Dominion for terrorism. Leyton convinced the Cadets to participate by presenting himself as a patriot seeking to protect Starfleet and Earth.

After Leyton's resignation, Red Squad remained part of Starfleet Academy's training program. Years later, Nog followed in Wesley Crusher's footsteps by joining the Red Squad Cadets, who had become the sole crew of the USS Valiant after their senior officer's death. Cadet Watters took command of the Valiant and decided to fulfill their original mission, which involved gathering intelligence on a new Jem'Hadar battleship. However, Watters was not adequately prepared for the challenges of leadership and ended up getting the majority of his crew killed when he engaged the battleship in direct combat beyond their capabilities.

Why Red Squad Was Worse Than Nova Squadron

Nova Squadron's compliance with Nick's plan to conceal the true circumstances surrounding Joshua Albert's demise stemmed from their panic-induced mistake. By sacrificing himself to preserve his team's Starfleet careers, Nick demonstrated his acceptance of responsibility. His subsequent reaction to being wrongly accused of causing Josh Albert's death in the final episode of Star Trek: Lower Decks Season 4 served as further evidence of his remorse. This is what distinguishes Nova Squadron from Red Squad, who made two erroneous choices resulting in a significantly higher death toll. Unlike the imperfect Locarno, the inexperienced and reckless "Captain" Tim Watters failed to protect his team.

Tim, unprepared for the burdens of responsibility, tragically lost his entire crew. It was unwise for Nick to attempt the banned and highly perilous Kolvoord Starburst maneuver in Star Trek: The Next Generation. However, the consequences of Tim Watters' decision to engage the Jem'Hadar battleship in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine were exponentially greater. With the Dominion War in full swing, such direct action should have been undertaken exclusively by a proficient team of seasoned Starfleet officers. Watters' disregard for Jake and Nog's criticisms ultimately led to the near annihilation of his entire crew. For this reason, his transgressions outweigh those of Nicholas Locarno.

Star Trek: The Next Generation is the third installment of the renowned sci-fi franchise. It follows the thrilling exploits of Captain Jean-Luc Picard and his crew aboard the USS Enterprise. This futuristic series takes place a century after the original and showcases Picard and his team as they venture across the galaxy in distinct, standalone episodes. Through these episodes, viewers delve into the intricate dynamics between the crew members and witness their engaging political discussions. While each episode stands on its own, the series also weaves together overarching storylines that unfold gradually, complemented by the release of four films that further develop these captivating narrative elements.

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, also known as DS9, is the fourth installment in the enduring Sci-Fi franchise, Star Trek. With creators Rick Berman and Michael Piller at the helm, this remarkable series showcases the talents of Avery Brooks, René Auberjonois, Terry Farrell, and Cirroc Lofton. Set in a space station adjacent to the planet Bajor, DS9 chronicles the adventures of a diverse group of individuals.

Editor's P/S

Comparing the Ineptitude: Assessing TNG's Nova Squadron vs DS9's Red Squad

Both Nova Squadron and Red Squad were esteemed factions composed of Starfleet Academy trainees. However, Red Squad's conduct was notably more reprehensible, leading to a greater number of casualties. While Nova Squadron, headed by Nick Locarno, made a regrettable error during a maneuver, they ultimately assumed accountability and safeguarded their team. Conversely, under the guidance of Tim Watters, Red Squad made impulsive choices that resulted in the loss of their entire crew.

Red Squad's decision to engage a Jem'Hadar battleship during the Dominion War proved to be a far riskier endeavor, leading to a greater loss of life compared to the dangerous mistake made by Nova Squadron. In the end, it is clear that Red Squad's actions were far more reckless and resulted in far greater consequences, making them the more inept of the two squadrons.