Beyond the Final Frontier: The Dark Side of the Federation's Tech
The Federation, known as the beacon of morality in Star Trek, has occasionally strayed from its virtuous path by resorting to unethical technologies From secretive organizations to dangerous biological weapons, here are six instances where the Federation's actions were morally questionable
In the vast Star Trek universe, numerous forces and empires have risen and fallen, yet the United Federation of Planets has remained a constant presence in nearly every aspect of Star Trek media. Regarded as the embodiment of virtue, the Federation typically portrays its crews working in service of its noble ideals. However, there have been instances in its history where the Federation has dabbled with technologies that have raised eyebrows both among the audience and the characters within the universe. Despite their intended role as the champions of righteousness, the Starfleet Federation occasionally succumbs to the allure of greater power.
6 Section 31
The utilization of advanced technologies by Section 31, such as the distressing holodeck psychological testing that involved manipulative tactics, presented a truly horrifying spectacle. This stark contrast to the Federation's core values of exploration and peace gave the impression of a government fixated on clandestine warfare rather than embodying the beloved organization cherished by its fans.
5 The Tartigrade
In Star Trek: Discovery, Captain Lorca's unwavering dedication to employing scientific advancements for the Federation's battle against the Klingons forms the central theme of the series. While the pursuit of scientific weaponry in the midst of an intergalactic conflict is understandable, their chosen methods were not without controversy.
Among the more peculiar technologies utilized by the Discovery was a living organism known as the Tartigrade. This alien creature was captured and held captive on the ship, serving as the pilot for their spore drive. While the Tartigrade suffered in confinement, its invaluable assistance allowed the Discovery to rescue numerous other beings. Nevertheless, this approach raises one of the timeless ethical dilemmas in the Star Trek universe.
4 The Borg Drone
Captain Picard of Star Trek: The Next Generation was a respected and honorable leader who consistently strived to do what was right. His strong moral compass guided his decisions, setting him apart from his superior, Admiral Nechayev. Nechayev's priorities differed when it came to the Borg, particularly in an opportunity she had to commit genocide against them.
The Borg, a formidable species, posed a significant threat. However, the Federation had always upheld the belief that all life should be treated with reverence. Despite this, Nechayev compelled Picard to issue an order to send a Borg Drone named Hugh to implant a program within the Borg Collective that would bring about their destruction. This directive resulted in a near-genocide and left Star Trek fans grappling with yet another moral quandary. Thankfully, Picard continues to be cherished as a beloved character, despite the complexities of his past decisions.
3 The Genesis Device
Starfleet's creation and utilization of various technological devices have raised doubts, but none compare to the ethical complications surrounding the Genesis Device. Dr. Carol Marcus developed this device with the intention of transforming uninhabitable planets into habitable ones. However, its potential for destruction far outweighed its intended purpose.
Although Khan was the one who sought to exploit the Genesis Device's terrifying capabilities on a populated planet, Starfleet should have exercised greater caution when authorizing the creation of such a powerful entity. Their awareness of its potential consequences suggests a desire to possess this weapon themselves or a disregard for the potential harm it could cause by making it accessible to others.
2 Biological Warfare
Sisko's decision to confront the self-proclaimed hero and terrorist, Michael Eddington, showcases his morally ambiguous nature within the Star Trek franchise. In response to Eddington's use of biological warfare against Cardassian colonies, Sisko adopts the same tactics, surprising many. He vows to continue targeting Maquis colonies until Eddington surrenders, ultimately capturing him. Although Sisko's actions violate some fundamental Starfleet principles, it is crucial to acknowledge that Starfleet's prioritization of peace with the ruthless Cardassians resulted in the displacement of millions of Federation citizens. This, in turn, led to the formation of the Maquis group, whom Starfleet labeled as terrorists for their desperate measures.
1 The USS-Vengeance
The Dreadnought-Class Starship introduced in Star Trek Into Darkness is a menacing force, completely devoid of any peaceful intentions, and represents the antithesis of Federation principles. Despite Admiral Marcus being exposed as a renegade and a villain on par with Khan himself, the creation of this ruthless Starship could not be undone.
Originating from a Section 31 project, although existing in a separate timeline from most of their endeavors, it spiraled out of control and resulted in the development of a lethal vessel. Similar to the Genesis Device, the USS Vengeance fell into Khan's possession, turning it into a formidable weapon. Remarkably, this Starship surpassed any previous Federation creations in its singular focus on warfare, even when the Federation was engaged in actual conflict.
