Beetlejuice: Unraveling the Dark Fan Theory

The Mysterious Deaths

Beetlejuice, the iconic horror comedy directed by Tim Burton, has enthralled audiences with its spooky world and enigmatic characters. The opening sequence introduces us to Adam and Barbara Maitland, played by Alec Baldwin and Geena Davis, whose tragic deaths set the stage for a twisted journey into the afterlife. The movie depicts their demise as a result of a fatal car accident, but a dark fan theory challenges this explanation, raising sinister questions about the true nature of their deaths.

Annie McEnroe as Jane Butterfield in Beetlejuice

In the eerie realm of Beetlejuice, death is a recurring theme, but the movie deliberately avoids exploring the possibility of murder. The deaths of the characters, including the civil servants and Beetlejuice himself, are all attributed to tragic accidents and implied suicides. However, the theory that Jane Butterfield, the realtor, orchestrated the deaths of Adam and Barbara introduces a much darker tone to the narrative, adding layers of intrigue and suspicion to their untimely demise.

Adam and Barbara in Beetlejuice

The Sinister Plot Unveiled

The long-standing fan theory suggests that Jane Butterfield had ulterior motives behind Adam and Barbara's deaths. According to the theory, Jane orchestrated their demise in a calculated attempt to sell the Maitland's house for substantial profits. Her relentless pursuit to convince the Maitlands to sell their home, coupled with her fixation on monetary gains, raises chilling speculations about her involvement in their tragic fate. The theory delves into Jane's suspicious behavior and reactions, casting a shadow of doubt over the seemingly accidental nature of the deaths.

Geena Davis and Alec Baldwin in Beetlejuice

The fan theory paints a disturbing picture of Jane's manipulative actions, insinuating that she may have orchestrated the presence of the dog on the bridge, leading to the fatal accident. This revelation redefines Jane as a potential antagonist, driven by greed and indifference towards the lives of Adam and Barbara. Her calculated approach to secure a profitable deal at any cost adds a layer of malevolence to her character, challenging the audience's perception of her role in the Maitlands' tragedy.

Adam and Barbara in the attic in Beetlejuice

The Deleted Scene: A Compelling Clue

A deleted alternate ending scene from Beetlejuice provides further credence to the dark fan theory. The scene depicts Jane's relentless pursuit of selling the house, even after the Maitlands' deaths, emphasizing her insatiable greed and disregard for ethical boundaries. Her persistent efforts to persuade Charles and Delia Deetz to sell the house, despite their refusal, underscore her unscrupulous nature and the extent of her ambition. The deleted scene aligns with the theory, reinforcing the notion of Jane's sinister intentions and her willingness to go to extreme lengths to achieve her financial goals.

The dog standing on the wood plank in the bridge during Adam & Barbara's Beetlejuice death scene

The implications of Jane's dark plans extend beyond the original movie, hinting at the potential for her return in Beetlejuice 2. If the theory holds true, Jane's presence in the sequel could introduce a compelling subplot, intensifying the conflict and showcasing her as a formidable adversary. Beetlejuice 2 has the opportunity to delve deeper into Jane's villainous persona, unraveling the true extent of her treacherous schemes and solidifying her as a formidable force to be reckoned with.

Lydia looking shocked in Beetlejuice with a red background