Analyzing Neagley's Return in Reacher Season 3: Unveiling a Troubling Narrative Twist

While the potential return of Neagley in Reacher season 3 is exciting, it could also pose a concerning story problem. The show is set two years and seven months after Jack Reacher leaves Margrave at the end of season 1. Season 2 of the Amazon series introduces significant changes by shifting the setting to New York, where Reacher teams up with his former colleagues from the U.S. Army's 110th MP Special Investigations Unit.

These alterations in season 2 of Reacher not only allow for a larger scale of action and drama but also raise the stakes for the main characters. Neagley, who plays a more prominent role in season 2 after a brief appearance in season 1, emerges as a key ally who involves Reacher in the main mission. Although Neagley's investigative skills and dynamic with Reacher add depth to the storyline in season 2, her return in season 3 may not have the same impact.

Reacher's Premise Means He Can't Keep Calling Neagley For Backup

Neagley's recurring season 1 and 2 appearances means she cannot be in season 3

Maria Sten as Neagley and Alan Richtson as Jack Reacher in Reacher season 2 - Neagley's recurring season 1 and 2 appearances means she cannot be in season 3 - Reacher's Premise Means He Can't Keep Calling Neagley For Backup

In the first season of Reacher, the main character, along with his friends Roscoe and Finlay, faces a situation where they are outnumbered by their enemies. He turns to Neagley for assistance. In the second season, there is another encounter between Reacher and Neagley, this time with Neagley seeking Reacher's help. These seasons have shown that when Reacher and Neagley team up, they become a formidable duo. The conclusion of the second season hints at Neagley making a return, as Reacher considers the members of the 110th his family. However, having Neagley appear in every season alongside Reacher has its drawbacks.

Neagley's Presence Dilutes Reacher's Self-Sufficiency

It's important to consider how the portrayal of Reacher in the Lee Child books and Amazon show impacts the character's self-sufficiency. In both mediums, Reacher is depicted as a lone wolf who only seeks help when absolutely necessary. However, Neagley's frequent appearances in Reacher's crime-solving adventures go against this established trait. While the show has highlighted the strong bond between Reacher and Roscoe, Neagley's recurring presence risks deviating too far from the source material and diluting Reacher's self-sufficiency. Although Neagley has been a valuable addition to the show, her return in season 3 raises some concerns.

Reacher seems less like the show's main character when Neagley around

reacher-season-3-release-update-avoids-1-problem-that-hurt-amazon-s-season-2 - Reacher seems less like the show's main character when Neagley around - Neagley's Presence Dilutes Reacher's Self-Sufficiency

Jack Reacher is often seen as a tough and independent character who can easily defeat multiple enemies on his own. In the prison fight scene of Reacher season 1, he fought off several inmates without getting hurt. However, if Reacher starts depending on Neagley for help, he may seem less intimidating than he did in season 1.

When Neagley assists him, Reacher doesn't have to do much thinking and is mainly seen as the strong one in their partnership.

In the world of procedural investigative work, Reacher is known for his sharp detective skills. While his methods can be unconventional and aggressive at times, Reacher season 1 shows that he is a unique blend of both brains and brawn. On the other hand, Neagley, as seen in season 2, surpasses Reacher in intelligence, adding value to the Amazon series. One recurring funny moment involves Reacher teasing Neagley by asking, "I ever tell you you're smart, Neagley?"

Having Neagley by his side means Reacher doesn't have to rely on his own intellect as much and is often seen as just the "muscle." This shifts him away from the solitary figure he was originally meant to be. Neagley's presence, being a significant figure from Reacher's past, adds complexity to his character. However, their partnership also takes away from Reacher's individuality and the appeal of his lone-wolf persona.

Neagley Deserves Her Own Spinoff More Than A Reacher Season 3 Return

Reacher seasons 1 and 2 have laid the foundation for a Neagley spin-off

Alan Ritchson's Jack Reacher and Maria Sten's Frances Neagley in Amazon's Reacher - Reacher seasons 1 and 2 have laid the foundation for a Neagley spin-off - Neagley Deserves Her Own Spinoff More Than A Reacher Season 3 Return

Neagley's role as a private investigator in Reacher season 2 highlights her strong sense of justice and sharp investigative skills. She deserves her own show where she can solve crimes and showcase her abilities, similar to Reacher. Throughout the season, she proves to be a formidable character, often outshining Reacher and engaging in intense fistfights. Instead of being a recurring secondary protagonist in Reacher season 3, Neagley should have her own spinoff series to further explore her character and talents.

Reacher seasons 1 and 2 are avaliable on Prime Video for streaming.

Editor's P/S:

The article raises valid concerns about the potential impact of Neagley's return on the character of Reacher. By diluting his self-sufficiency and overshadowing his individuality, Neagley's presence could undermine the core appeal of the show. The suggestion of a Neagley spinoff is an intriguing alternative, allowing her to shine as a standalone character while preserving the integrity of Reacher's solitary nature.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to include Neagley in Reacher season 3 is a delicate one. While her investigative skills and dynamic with Reacher add depth, the show must prioritize the character's established traits and avoid detracting from his self-reliance. A Neagley spinoff would allow both characters to flourish, showcasing their strengths without compromising the essence of Reacher.