American Horror Stories Season 3: Complete Organ Cast & Character Breakdown

Spoiler alert: The following article contains spoilers from American Horror Stories season 3, episode 4.

Summary

In American Horror Stories season 3, episode 4, the focus is on Toby, a man with a deep aversion towards women, who encounters a mysterious woman on a dating app. However, their encounter takes a sinister turn when Toby awakens to find his kidney missing.

The episode unravels with unexpected turns as Toby delves into the mystery surrounding his ordeal. He stumbles upon Magna Mater, an underground organization involved in organ theft, and realizes that Natessa, the woman he met, is somehow linked to it.

In "Organ," the fourth episode of American Horror Stories season 3, Toby takes center stage as a man consumed by hatred towards women and fixated on a dating app called Pincher. However, this episode delves deeper into his story by introducing a host of significant characters. Among them is Sasha, Toby's coworker and friend, portrayed by Havana Rose Liu, who harbors a secret love for Toby but ultimately betrays him. The episode also showcases the presence of Detective Markham and Detective Grant, operatives for Magna Mater, as well as a minor role played by Patrick Breen as the Auctioneer. As the season unfolds just in time for Halloween, this particular episode explores the horrors of an underground organ trafficking ring. Although the initial moments seem innocuous, with Toby's disparaging beliefs about women being the only unsettling factor, a chilling twist occurs when he encounters a mysterious woman from Pincher.

Raúl Castillo As Toby Arcaño

"Organ" unfolds with a series of captivating surprises, most notably a shocking revelation at the very end of the episode. Toby embarks on a quest to uncover the truth behind an unsettling incident that occurred on the night he brought Natessa home. After being drugged by her, Toby awakens to the horrifying realization that his left kidney has been removed and replaced by something else entirely. Through the course of the story, viewers are introduced to the diverse cast of characters and their intricate involvement in Toby's distressing encounter with an unexplained radical nephrectomy in season 3, episode 4 of American Horror Stories."

In season 3 of American Horror Stories, Toby Arcaño, portrayed by Raúl Castillo, faces significant challenges when it comes to relationships with women. His divorce has left him deeply disillusioned, leading him to engage in casual encounters without establishing any genuine connections. Unfortunately for Toby, his experiences take a dark turn when he encounters a woman on Pincher who has sinister intentions: she plans to remove his left kidney and sell it to the highest bidder. Upon waking up from the surgery, Toby is determined to uncover the truth behind his ordeal and seek revenge.

Besides his appearance on American Horror Stories season 3, episode 4, Castillo has showcased his talent in numerous other TV shows and movies. Fans may recognize him as Richie Donado Ventura from HBO's Looking, or from his performances in Amexicano or Cold Weather. Castillo has also made notable appearances in Knives Out, Army of the Dead, Hustle, Gotham, Riverdale, Atypical, and Seven Seconds.

Emily Browning As Natessa

In American Horror Stories season 3, episode 4, Emily Browning takes on the role of Natessa, one of Toby's encounters on Pincher. Unlike his previous partners, Natessa has ulterior motives for getting involved with Toby. Her intention is not to pursue a romantic relationship or engage in sexual activities with him. Instead, she harbors the sinister plan of stealing one of his kidneys. As the story unfolds, Toby discovers the shocking truth that Natessa is connected to an underground organ theft ring known as Magna Mater, and it is they who have targeted Toby. After luring Toby into a drug-induced slumber in his own apartment, Natessa grants access to a team of skilled surgeons who perform a daring operation to remove one of Toby's kidneys and replace it with a new one.

Although Natessa plays a British actress in "Organ," in real life Browning is Australian. She has appeared in various projects including The Echo of Thunder, Ghost Ship, High Flyers, Something in the Air, Blue Heelers, The Uninvited, and Sucker Punch. However, Browning is most recognized for her portrayals of Violet Baudelaire in Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events, Laura Moon in American Gods, and Sierra in The Affair.

Havana Rose Liu As Sasha

Havana Rose Liu portrays the character of Sasha in the fourth episode of the third season of American Horror Stories. Sasha, who is a coworker and close friend of Toby, is depicted as one of the numerous women in his life. Although Sasha secretly harbors feelings for Toby, he remains completely oblivious due to his preoccupation with a dating app. This lack of awareness on Toby's part may have led to Sasha's ultimate betrayal towards the end of the episode. It is revealed that Sasha has a connection to Magna Mater.

Cameron Cowperthwaite As Wyatt

Liu has an extensive filmography which includes notable appearances in Mayday, The Sky Is Everywhere, No Exit, and The Chair. However, it was her role as Isabel in the 2023 comedy Bottoms that brought her widespread recognition. In addition to her acting career, Liu is also actively involved in the modeling industry.

In American Horror Stories season 3, Cameron Cowperthwaite portrays the character of Wyatt, a brilliant tech genius. Toby enlists Wyatt's assistance in locating Magna Mater. Prior to this, Toby and Wyatt were acquainted as Wyatt used to operate an escort service that Toby occasionally utilized. Toby offers a substantial amount of money to Wyatt for his expertise in scouring the dark web to track down Natessa, and he proves successful. This skilled hacker aids Toby in gaining access to an exclusive auction with a buy-in cost of $100,000. It is during this event that Toby discovers he has become a target of an underground operation involved in illegal organ trafficking.

Cowperthwaite, an American Horror Story universe veteran, is an actor who has appeared in both the main series and the anthology television show on Hulu. In American Horror Stories season 2, episode 7, he portrayed the character Charlie, and in American Horror Story season 7, he played Speed Wagon. Alongside his involvement in Ryan Murphy's horror shows, Cowperthwaite has also been seen in Shameless, Dahmer - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, Station 19, NCIS, The Rookie, and 9-1-1: Lone Star.

Susan Pourfar As Detective Markham

Playing one of the investigators in American Horror Stories season 3, episode 4, Susan Pourfar portrays Detective Markham. Markham visits Toby at the hospital to inquire about the woman who drugged him and may have been connected to his radical nephrectomy. Later in the episode, she reappears when Toby reaches out to her and her partner with information about the auction he attended. Suspecting him of Natessa's murder, Detective Markham reveals her true colors, proving she isn't as law-abiding as she initially seemed. Alongside her role in the Hulu anthology series, Pourfar has graced the screens in Madam Secretary, Scandal, Manchester by the Sea, and Black Mirror.

Jeff Adler As Detective Grant

Drew Moore As Dr. Son

Jeff Adler portrays Detective Grant — Detective Markham's partner in the Hulu anthology horror series "Organ." Detective Grant collaborates with Detective Markham to investigate Toby's mysterious disappearance and plays a crucial role when Toby tips off the police about the secret underground organ auction. However, a surprising turn of events occurs after apprehending Toby for Natessa's murder, as Grant and Markham uncover their true allegiance to Magna Mater. Jeff Adler, known for his appearances in Rosewood, Modern Family, Greyhound, Beautiful Boy, FBI, Blue Bloods, and Hightown, appears in the series.

Drew Moore portrays Dr. Son in episode 4 of season 3 of American Horror Stories. Dr. Son provides medical treatment to Toby after his left kidney is forcibly removed, and he reveals to Toby that an unidentified object has been implanted inside him. Regrettably, Dr. Son is unaware of the nature of this foreign entity, leaving Toby to discover through Magna Mater that it is a newly engineered organ. Prior to his role in this Hulu series, Moore has appeared in Power Book III: Raising Kanan, FBI: Most Wanted, Law & Order: Organized Crime, and White House Plumbers.

Patrick Breen As The Auctioneer

Maria Tucci As Dr. Krystal

Patrick Breen takes on the role of the Auctioneer in the third season of American Horror Stories. In this capacity, his character orchestrates an auction for an organ theft ring, which Toby happens to witness halfway through the episode. Breen may be familiar to viewers from his appearances in Men in Black, Whole Day Down, Cirque de Freak: The Vampire's Assistant, A Series of Unfortunate Events, The Blacklist, Bull, and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.

In American Horror Stories season 3, episode 4, Dr. Krystal, portrayed by Maria Tucci, makes her entrance as Toby's therapist. Their therapy session delves into Toby's problematic relationships with women, and it is revealed that Sasha recommended Toby to see Dr. Krystal. Alongside her appearances in Spin City, Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, Law & Order, and The Slap, Tucci has an impressive background as a stage actress. Notably, she earned the Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Play in 1967 for her role in The Rose Tattoo.

Laila Robbins As Lee

Lastly, Laila Robbins captivates as Lee in the chilling Hulu anthology horror series. Lee, the supervisor of Toby, becomes increasingly critical of his recent performance at work due to his preoccupation with a dating app. However, as the story progresses, it is unveiled that Lee's resentment towards Toby stems from her connections with Magna Mater. Besides her phenomenal portrayal in American Horror Stories, Laila Robbins may be familiar to fans from notable works such as Planes, Trains, & Automobiles, The Blacklist, Dr. Death, The Boys, The Walking Dead, The Crowded Room, and Gen V​​​​​.