Accuracy Rating of Da 5 Bloods by Historian Bill Allison

Unveiling the Accuracy of Da 5 Bloods

Spike Lee's cinematic masterpiece, Da 5 Bloods, has captivated audiences with its powerful storytelling and exceptional performances. Released in 2020, the film follows the journey of four African American war veterans as they return to Vietnam in search of buried treasure and the remains of their fallen comrade. Starring Delroy Lindo, Clarke Peters, Norm Lewis, Isiah Whitlock Jr., Jonathan Majors, and the late Chadwick Boseman, Da 5 Bloods has received widespread acclaim, even earning a nomination at the 27th SAG Awards.

However, historian Bill Allison raises a critical flag on the film's accuracy, shedding light on certain scenes that may not align with historical reality. In a recent analysis on Insider, Allison scrutinizes a particular scene from Da 5 Bloods, rating its accuracy a mere 5 out of 10. His analysis focuses on the implausibility of a helicopter remaining stationary amid gunfire and highlights the discrepancies in the portrayal of the Viet Cong's retreat.

Allison's expertise in history and military strategy allows him to identify the flaws in the scene, emphasizing that a helicopter would not have stayed in one place for an extended period while under direct fire. He points out the absence of additional helicopters providing cover and support, highlighting the vulnerability of a stationary aircraft to rocket-propelled grenades. As the scene unfolds, the inevitable happens, and the helicopter is ultimately destroyed by the Viet Cong's attack.

In addition to critiquing specific scenes, Allison also sheds light on the significant presence of African American soldiers in Vietnam. He emphasizes their disproportionate involvement in combat and casualties compared to their representation in the U.S. population. This crucial aspect of the war is an integral part of the film's narrative, reflecting the realities faced by Black soldiers during the Vietnam War.

Analyzing the Crucial Scene

The scene that historian Bill Allison analyzes occurs during the initial flashback of Da 5 Bloods. Set near a fallen military C-47, the "Bloods" encounter hostile forces and engage in a fierce battle. Allison argues that the scene's accuracy is questionable due to the unrealistic portrayal of the helicopter's actions and the lack of proper support.

According to Allison, a helicopter would not have remained stationary in the midst of intense gunfire for an extended period. He highlights the importance of having additional helicopters nearby to provide cover and assistance in such a dangerous situation. The destruction of the helicopter's tail, as depicted in the scene, could have potentially been averted with better support and tactical decisions.

While Da 5 Bloods is not rooted in a true story, it serves as a poignant portrayal of the Black military experience during the Vietnam War. The film sheds light on the struggles, sacrifices, and racial injustices endured by African American soldiers. It also references historical figures like Milton L. Olive III, who was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor for his heroism in Vietnam, and the tragic loss of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., a vocal opponent of the war.

Reflecting on Black Veterans' Stories

Inspired by the oral history book "Bloods: An Oral History of the Vietnam War by Black Veterans," Da 5 Bloods offers a unique perspective on the experiences of Black men who served in the war. Spike Lee's vision strives to capture their stories and provide a platform for their voices to be heard.

Despite the ongoing debate about the film's combat accuracy, Da 5 Bloods offers a valuable insight into the untold narratives of Black veterans. It highlights their contributions, sacrifices, and the challenges they faced both on the battlefield and upon their return home. By exploring their experiences, the film invites viewers to reflect on the profound impact of their service and the need for a more inclusive understanding of history.

Whether you are a history buff or a movie enthusiast, Da 5 Bloods on Netflix is a must-watch. It not only entertains but also encourages viewers to contemplate the untold stories of Black veterans and the lasting effects of war. Spike Lee's masterful storytelling paired with the exceptional performances of the cast makes Da 5 Bloods a film that will leave a lasting impact on its audience.

Isiah Whitlock Jr., Norm Lewis, Clarke Peters, Delroy Lindo, and Jonathan Majors looking at the ground in Da 5 Bloods - How Accurate Is Da 5 Bloods?

Watch the Analysis

For a deeper dive into the accuracy of Vietnam War scenes in movies, check out Vietnam War Historian's breakdown on Insider: