9 Controversial JRPGs Redefining Gameplay Mechanics

While people may believe they have a solid understanding of JRPGs, this genre actually encompasses a diverse range of mechanics that become apparent when one delves deep into playing them. Some JRPGs deviate so significantly from the genre's traditional conventions that players might not initially appreciate what they have to offer.

The games listed below undeniably possess a dedicated fanbase, but there are equally as many individuals who found themselves unimpressed by their mechanics and overall structure, despite their potential for innovation. At the very least, one must acknowledge and respect a game's audacious ambition to experiment with something distinct.

8. Live A Live

Anthology JRPG Combining Numerous Separate Narratives

Metacritic Score: 81

Metacritic User Score: 7.5

Live A Live

Platform: SNES

Release Date: September 2, 1994

Developer: Square

Publisher: Square

This JRPG only reached Western markets in 2022, and the reason for Square's delayed localization becomes evident. Initially, the game did not receive much acclaim and perhaps would have been considered too unconventional for Western gamers. Critics criticized its brevity and found its ending unsatisfying. Nevertheless, the game's distinctive structure cannot be disregarded.

7. Final Fantasy 2

Players have the freedom to explore multiple campaigns in any desired sequence, each with its own unique storyline that ultimately converges in a final chapter. Notably, Director Takashi Tokita would later create Chrono Trigger, a game that also ingeniously combines various settings and time periods.

Stats Increase As You Use Them Like In Elder Scrolls

Metacritic Score: 63

Metacritic User Score: 6.6

Score Based On The PSP Version

Final Fantasy 2

Platform(s): Nintendo Entertainment System, Android, iOS, Game Boy Advance, PC, PS1, PS4, PSP, WonderSwan

Released: December 17, 1988

Developer(s): Square

Publisher(s): Square

In most JRPGs, players are well-acquainted with the typical leveling system, where the party gains experience from battles and gradually improves their stats and abilities. However, Final Fantasy 2 takes a different approach. Rather than leveling up, the party's stats and abilities grow based on the specific abilities they utilize.

Defense and attack in this game work differently than in other RPGs. As you get attacked, your defense stat increases, making you harder to defeat. On the other hand, using the attack command boosts your attack stat, making your offensive moves more powerful. This unique mechanic, reminiscent of the Elder Scrolls series rather than Final Fantasy, adds an innovative twist to gameplay. However, it is worth noting that this system can be easily exploited by attacking your own party members, leading to an unbalanced and overpowered character.

6. Legend Of Legaia

Combo System Only Its Sequel Replicated

No Metacritic Score Available

Legend of Legaia

Platform: PlayStation 2

Release Date: October 16, 1998

Publisher: Sony

While Legend of Legaia may have been overlooked as just another JRPG on the PS1, a console known for its abundance of the genre, it is essential for more gamers to take notice of its strikingly unique combat mechanics. Rather than the typical approach of selecting the attack command, players are required to input a sequence of punches and kicks during each turn, resulting in a powerful combo unleashed upon the enemy.

Depending on the input combinations, players have the opportunity to unleash special attacks featuring their own distinctive animations. Additionally, as the party levels up, they progressively gain the ability to execute lengthier combos with each turn.

5. Final Fantasy 16

Real-Time Combat Based On Character Action Games

Metacritic Score: 87

Metacritic User Score: 8.1

Final Fantasy 16

Platform(s) PS5Released June 22, 2023Developer(s) Square EnixPublisher(s) Square Enix

Final Fantasy 16 deviates not only from the series but also from the JRPG genre entirely. The combat is completely different from the traditional turn-based system. Instead, players engage in real-time battles, allowing for unrestricted movement and immediate attack releases. Timing is crucial for executing successful parries and dodges. While Square's franchises such as Kingdom Hearts incorporate real-time combat, Final Fantasy 16 shares more similarities with games like Bayonetta or Devil May Cry. This shift in gameplay may disappoint some long-time fans but also has the potential to attract a fresh audience.

For what it's worth, Our website loved the game and the new direction it went into with the series. Read more about it in the review.

4. Nier

False Endings With More Content As Players Start A New Game

Metacritic Score: 67

Metacritic User Score: 8.5

Nier

Platform(s) PS3, Xbox 360Released April 27, 2010Developer(s) CaviaPublisher(s) Square Enix

These days, games like Metal Gear Solid V and Control play with players' minds by rolling credits early on, only to reveal that there is much more game left to be played. Nier was one of the pioneers of this tactic, although its eccentricity caused it to receive mediocre reviews initially. However, the user score indicated that consumers were more enamored with the game's offerings.

Players have the option to start a new game multiple times in order to unlock additional content that delves deeper into the game's story. The sequel, Nier: Automata, employed the same narrative tactic, which had an even greater impact. Thankfully, the sequel was better received, thanks in part to its improved combat mechanics.

3. Xenosaga

Trilogy Of Directly Connected RPGs

Metacritic Score: 83

Metacritic User Score: 8.1

Episode II Metacritic Score: 73

Episode II Metacritic User Score: 7.4

Xenosaga Episode I: Der Wille zur Macht

Platform: PS2

Release Date: February 25, 2003

Developer: Monolith Soft

Publisher: Namco

Xenogears garnered critical acclaim on the original PlayStation due to its distinctive storytelling. The three Xenosaga games on the PS2, however, did not receive the same level of universal praise. These games were highly linear and included prolonged cutscenes with minimal gameplay.

However, its ambition in the RPG genre was unprecedented. While numerous JRPGs are typically part of a series, Xenosaga stood out as a trilogy where each installment served as a direct continuation of the preceding one. Strikingly, the original vision encompassed a six-game saga. However, due to the underwhelming reception of the second game, the narrative was ultimately concluded within three games instead.

2. Dragon's Dogma

Online Component Where Players Utilize Other Players' Characters In Their Party

Metacritic Score: 75

Metacritic User Score: 7.9

Dragon's Dogma

Platform(s) PS3, Xbox 360Released May 22, 2012Developer(s) CapcomPublisher(s) Capcom

Dragon's Dogma is undeniably a JRPG, although it draws inspiration from Western examples of the genre. One of its standout features is an innovative online component, where players can have a character in their party created by another player.

While the game's vast and ambitious design did result in some bugs and performance issues, those who could look beyond these technical challenges were rewarded with a truly one-of-a-kind experience. The game's dedicated following eventually led to the exciting news of a sequel being announced.

1. Parasite Eve

Mixing The JRPG And Survival Horror Genres

Metacritic Score: 81

Metacritic User Score: 8.8

Parasite Eve

Parasite Eve, developed by Square and published by Square on September 9, 1998, stands out from other JRPGs in several ways. It incorporates a modern-day setting and blends survival horror elements into its JRPG mechanics. In addition to comprehending its battle system, exploring the environment for items and resources is equally crucial.

The game's setting is quite unique and disturbing considering the time it was released. It starts in an opera house where the majority of its audience members suddenly burst into flames near the main character. While not the first contemporary JRPG to explore this type of setting, it is uncommon, and only recently has the Like a Dragon series gained popularity as a notable example.

Editor's P/S

1. In the realm of JRPGs, there have always been titles that push the boundaries of traditional gameplay mechanics, resulting in experiences that both excite and divide players. One such game is Final Fantasy 2, which takes a unique approach to character progression. Instead of the familiar leveling system, Final Fantasy 2 introduces a system where character stats and abilities improve based on their usage. This innovative mechanic, reminiscent of the Elder Scrolls series, adds depth and strategy to gameplay. However, it also has its drawbacks, as players can exploit the system by attacking their own party members to gain an unfair advantage. Despite its flaws, Final Fantasy 2's willingness to experiment with new ideas is commendable and makes it a memorable entry in the JRPG genre.

2. Another JRPG that challenges conventional gameplay mechanics is Legend of Legaia. This PlayStation 2 title features a unique combat system that requires players to input a sequence of punches and kicks during each turn. These inputs result in powerful combos that can devastate enemies. The game's combat is fast-paced and engaging, and it offers a satisfying sense of progression as players unlock new combos and abilities. While Legend of Legaia may not have received the same level of attention as other JRPGs on the PlayStation 2, its innovative combat mechanics make it a standout title that deserves recognition.