15 Heart-Wrenching Supernatural Moments That Tugged at Fans' Emotions

Summary

Supernatural

The Winchesters experienced numerous heart-wrenching moments that brought fans to tears. Their lives were constantly plagued by tragedy, heartbreak, and selflessness, capturing the attention of viewers.

Certain scenes from the show were particularly heart-wrenching, such as the devastating losses of Mary, Jessica, Ellen, and Jo. These moments struck a deep chord within fans, eliciting intense emotions and bringing tears to their eyes.

The final season of

Supernatural

The content was a whirlwind of emotions, as Castiel made a selfless sacrifice and Dean met his final demise, leaving viewers heartbroken and in tears. While the ending may have felt unjust, it was a fitting conclusion for Dean's character. Throughout Supernatural, there were moments of such profound sadness that they consistently moved fans to tears. Each season brought escalating violence and heartbreaking circumstances, yet viewers remained captivated by the gripping storyline. Despite enduring countless trials, Dean and Sam Winchester always persevered, never losing sight of their responsibility as hunters of supernatural creatures.

15. Mary & Jessica Are Killed (Season 1, Episode 1)

Supernatural characters perished with such frequency that fans lost count, yet their demise never failed to evoke sadness. Sam and Dean's lives were fraught with misery, grief, and selflessness, which captivated viewers and provided an escape from the real world for an hour or two. Nevertheless, certain scenes in Supernatural struck a deeper chord, prompting fans to shed tears uncontrollably.

Supernatural's inaugural episode, "Pilot," introduces viewers to a heartbreaking tragedy that strikes both Mary Winchester and Jessica Moore, despite their separation by decades. The initial devastation experienced by Sam upon the loss of his girlfriend could bring tears to anyone's eyes, but this particular scene becomes even more distressing upon subsequent viewings. With knowledge of what lies ahead, audiences can't help but develop deep empathy for the Winchester brothers.

14. John Saves Dean (Season 2, Episode 1)

John Winchester falls short of being Supernatural's father of the year. Consumed by his relentless quest to uncover his wife's killer, he neglects the task of raising his own children, leaving them to fend for themselves. Nevertheless, John harbors love for both his sons, even if it is not always evident. This affection becomes apparent when he realizes that Dean's life hangs in the balance after a traumatic car accident. In a selfless act, he strikes a deal with Azazel, sacrificing himself to spend a century in Hell so that Dean can continue living. The boys are left to face the permanent loss of their father, marking only the beginning of their heart-wrenching journey.

13. Sam Has To Slay Madison (Season 2, Episode 17)

The early seasons of Supernatural inflict a unique torment on the viewers by introducing the brothers to temporary love interests who share a genuine chemistry with them, only to tragically eradicate them from the storyline. This is exemplified by Madison, who unexpectedly unveils her identity as a werewolf. Having formed a strong bond with Sam Winchester, Madison implores him to end her life before she poses a danger to others. Still haunted by the loss of Jessica, Sam now finds himself compelled to eliminate the first woman he truly cares for and envisions a future with. The weight of this burden proves to be overwhelming.

12. Jake Stabs Sam (Season 2, Episode 21)

Sam and Dean meet their demise multiple times throughout the Supernatural series, but nothing quite compares to the impact of their very first death. In the gripping season 2 finale, Sam unwillingly finds himself thrust into Azazel's deadly Hunger Games, where he comes agonizingly close to emerging victorious, leaving Jake Talley incapacitated. Tragically, Jake regains consciousness and fatally stabs Sam, delivering one of the most heart-wrenching moments in the show's history. As Sam takes his last breath in Dean's loving embrace, the latter is overwhelmed by guilt for his inability to protect his brother, prompting him to make a devastating pact with Azazel in the subsequent episode.

11. Mary Shares Her Deepest Desire (Season 4, Episode 3)

In Supernatural's fourth season, Castiel transports Dean back in time, allowing him to encounter his parents. During this time-traveling escapade, Dean learns that the family's involvement in monster-hunting extends further back than he ever imagined. Engaging in a heartfelt conversation, Dean's mother discloses her desire to escape the hunting life and enjoy a peaceful family existence. In an emotional moment, viewers are moved as Mary expresses her determination to shield her children from the perils of hunting, leaving Dean struggling to hold back tears.

10. Dean Talks To Sam About Hell (Season 4, Episode 10)

The Dean's Hell storyline is undoubtedly one of the most heart-wrenching arcs in the entire series. It is nearly impossible to hold back tears during the scene where Dean finally opens up to Sam about his "sins." Haunted by his time in Hell, Dean vividly remembers the torture he endured and the disturbing satisfaction he found in inflicting pain on others. Consumed by remorse and unable to forgive himself, Dean's confession leaves Sam utterly bewildered.

9. Ellen & Jo Sacrifice Themselves (Season 5, Episode 10)

8. Lisa & Ben Forget Dean (Season 6, Episode 21)

Ellen and Jo Harvelle, the beloved duo of a mother and daughter, meet an exceptionally tragic fate in the Supernatural universe. These two courageous women choose to unite forces with Sam and Dean in their mission to defeat Lucifer, but unfortunately, it leads to their untimely demise. Upon witnessing Jo's dire injuries, Ellen makes the heart-wrenching decision to remain by her daughter's side, ultimately sacrificing herself by detonating a bomb, which is designed to eliminate the hellhounds threatening their lives. In a scene that leaves spectators devastated, an emotive Ellen embraces Jo's lifeless body, and with immense sorrow, she pulls the trigger, giving up her own life in a valiant attempt to save the Winchesters.

8. Lisa & Ben Forget Dean (Season 6, Episode 21)

In Supernatural season 6, Dean is forced to bid farewell to his found family, Lisa and Ben Braeden. Their lives become endangered after Lisa's body is possessed by a demon, leading Dean to ask Castiel to erase their memories of him. Castiel ensures Lisa's recovery and erases any recollection of Dean, causing him to visit her in the hospital incognito. It is ironic and unforgettable for Dean to witness the realization that neither Lisa nor Ben remembers him.

7. Bobby Singer Dies (Season 7, Episode 10)

Bobby proves to be a superior father figure to Sam and Dean compared to John, taking on the role of their caretaker and consistently being there for them. However, in Supernatural season 7, Bobby falls into a coma after being shot by Dick Roman, the leader of the Leviathans. This emotionally charged episode delves into Bobby's past through flashbacks, thanks to the reaper, as he desperately tries to regain consciousness long enough to deliver a crucial message to Sam and Dean. Ultimately, Bobby succeeds in his mission, affectionately calling them "idjits" one final time before passing away.

6. Dean Learns That Kevin Is Dead (Season 9, Episode 9)

In the ninth season of Supernatural, the Winchester brothers face yet another devastating blow. Unbeknownst to Dean, Gadreel, who is secretly working with Metatron, takes control of Sam's body and tragically kills their loyal companion and friend, Kevin Tran. Dean is consumed by guilt, having lost both his brother and Kevin to the treachery of Gadreel. The sight of him sitting silently, tears streaming down his face, whispering Kevin's name, shattered the hearts of devoted fans.

5. Eldon Murders Charlie (Season 10, Episode 21)

Сharlie Bradbury, Sam and Dean's foster sister, is a devastating loss for the brothers, who have already suffered many other losses. In season 10 of Supernatural, the Winchesters find themselves up against the Stynes, a group determined to retrieve the Book of the Damned at any cost. Seeking Charlie's expertise, Sam and Dean ask her to decode the Book, which ultimately leads to her getting caught in the dangerous crossfire. Tragically, Charlie is discovered dead in her motel bathtub, a victim of Eldon Styne's brutal murder. This heart-wrenching event deeply affects Sam, Dean, and viewers alike. In fact, the death of Charlie infuriates dedicated Supernatural fans.

4. Dean Forgets Who He Is (Season 12, Episode 11)

In Supernatural's twelfth season, episode 11, titled "Regarding Dean," Dean finds himself in a desperate situation when a witch casts a curse on him, causing his memory to rapidly fade away. While the episode starts off lighthearted with enjoyable sequences, the mood takes a somber turn as Dean's recollection deteriorates. Particularly, the scene where Dean struggles to retain his identity, repetitively uttering his own name and the names of his loved ones, showcases astounding acting prowess, undoubtedly prompting viewers to shed a few tears.

3. Sam Is Forced To Kill Rowena (Season 15, Episode 3)

Rowena, the Winchesters' most unexpected ally, has a tumultuous relationship with them throughout Supernatural. However, as the series progresses, their bond deepens and they develop a profound love for each other. In the fifteenth season, Rowena assists Sam and Dean in a particularly harrowing spell that necessitates a human sacrifice. With all other options exhausted, Rowena makes the heartbreaking decision to offer up her own life, selecting Sam, her cherished favorite, to fulfill the role of executioner. In a heart-wrenching moment, Sam embraces Rowena and reluctantly plunges the blade into her, amplifying the intensity of the scene and bringing viewers to tears.

2. Castiel Makes The Ultimate Sacrifice (Season 15, Episode 18)

The final season of Supernatural is a rollercoaster of emotions from beginning to end, leaving fans bitter over Castiel's death. In an attempt to save himself from Death, Castiel bravely declares his love for Dean, allowing the Shadow to consume him while taking down Billie in the process. This long-awaited moment is filled with intense drama, but the fact that Castiel dies shortly after his revelation feels disappointing, to say the least. Thus, there are two reasons to shed tears during this heart-wrenching scene.

1. Dean Dies For Good (Season 15, Episode 20)

No Supernatural fan expected the finale to leave them unharmed, but the unexpected events that unfolded were beyond anyone's anticipation. Dean's statement about going down fighting becomes eerily true as he breathes his last breath in the embrace of Sam, concluding his arduous and exhausting hunter's odyssey. Devastated by the irrevocable loss of Dean, Sam bids farewell and clings onto his brother's lifeless form. While this conclusion is fitting for Dean, it remains incredibly unjust, leaving a lingering sense of unease.